Blum A L, Bethge H, Bode J C, Domschke W, Feurle G, Hackenberg K, Hammer B, Hüttemann W, Jung M, Kachel G
Division de Gastroentérologie, Centre Hospitalier, Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Gut. 1990 Jul;31(7):825-30. doi: 10.1136/gut.31.7.825.
A randomised controlled multicentre trial was performed in 160 patients with gastric ulcer, proved by endoscopy and biopsy, to compare ulcer healing with sucralfate and ranitidine (double blind double dummy design) and to assess the effect of maintenance treatment with sucralfate on ulcer recurrence (double blind placebo controlled design). The healing rates were similar with 4 g sucralfate suspension per day and 300 mg ranitidine per day (82% and 88% after 12 weeks, respectively). Of the 109 patients with healed ulcers, 92 were entered into the maintenance trial and treated with sucralfate tablets (2 g per day) or placebo tablets. Maintenance treatment with sucralfate delayed symptoms of gastric ulcer recurrence. Lifetable analysis showed significant differences between sucralfate and placebo, both after six months (p = 0.018) and after 12 months (p = 0.044). The rates of symptom recurrences were 13% and 34% after six months and 34% and 55% after 12 months for sucralfate and placebo, respectively. The rate of asymptomatic recurrences after 12 months was similar in the two groups (9% and 10%, respectively). The recurrence rate was higher in patients who had never taken non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs than in those who had but had stopped on admission to the study. It was also higher in patients with recurrent ulcer and in those with scarring deformation and narrowing of the pylorus. Maintenance treatment with sucralfate slowed the appearance of symptom recurrences of gastric ulcer.
对160例经内镜检查和活检证实为胃溃疡的患者进行了一项随机对照多中心试验,以比较硫糖铝和雷尼替丁治疗溃疡愈合的效果(双盲双模拟设计),并评估硫糖铝维持治疗对溃疡复发的影响(双盲安慰剂对照设计)。每日4g硫糖铝混悬液和每日300mg雷尼替丁的愈合率相似(12周后分别为82%和88%)。109例溃疡愈合的患者中,92例进入维持试验,接受硫糖铝片(每日2g)或安慰剂片治疗。硫糖铝维持治疗延缓了胃溃疡复发的症状。寿命表分析显示,硫糖铝组和安慰剂组在6个月后(p = 0.018)和12个月后(p = 0.044)均有显著差异。硫糖铝组和安慰剂组在6个月后的症状复发率分别为13%和34%,12个月后分别为34%和55%。两组12个月后的无症状复发率相似(分别为9%和10%)。从未服用过非甾体抗炎药的患者复发率高于服用过但在进入研究时已停药的患者。复发性溃疡患者以及有瘢痕变形和幽门狭窄的患者复发率也较高。硫糖铝维持治疗减缓了胃溃疡症状复发的出现。