Lebailly F, Lima L V P C, Clairemidi A, Aubert B, Guerard S, Chaibi Y, de Guise J, Fontaine C, Skalli W
Laboratoire de Biomécanique, Arts et Metiers ParisTech, 151 Boulevard de l'Hopital, 75013, Paris, France.
Surg Radiol Anat. 2012 Oct;34(8):757-65. doi: 10.1007/s00276-011-0884-9. Epub 2011 Oct 7.
Quantitative assessment of 3D clinical indices may be crucial for elbow surgery planning. 3D parametric modeling from bi-planar radiographs was successfully proposed for spine and lower limb clinical investigation as an alternative for CT-scan. The aim of this study was to adapt this method to the upper limb with a preliminary validation.
CT-scan 3D models of humerus, radius and ulna were obtained from 20 cadaveric upper limbs and yielded parametric models made of geometric primitives. Primitives were defined by descriptor parameters (diameters, angles...) and correlations between these descriptors were found. Using these correlations, a semi-automated reconstruction method of humerus using bi-planar radiographs was achieved: a 3D personalized parametric model was built, from which clinical parameters were computed [orientation and projections on bone surface of trochlea sulcus to capitulum (CTS) axis, trochlea sulcus anterior offset and width of distal humeral epiphysis]. This method was evaluated by accuracy compared to CT-scan and reproducibility.
Points-to-surface mean distance was 0.9 mm (2 RMS = 2.5 mm). For clinical parameters, mean differences were 0.4-1.9 mm and from 1.7° to 2.3°. All parameters except from angle formed by CTS axis and bi-epicondylar axis in transverse plane were reproducible. Reconstruction time was about 5 min.
The presented method provides access to morphological upper limb parameters with very low level of radiation. Preliminary in vitro validation for humerus showed that it is fast and accurate enough to be used in clinical daily practice as an alternative to CT-scan for total elbow arthroplasty pre operative evaluation.
三维临床指标的定量评估对于肘部手术规划可能至关重要。从双平面X线片进行三维参数建模已成功应用于脊柱和下肢临床研究,作为计算机断层扫描(CT)的替代方法。本研究的目的是将该方法应用于上肢并进行初步验证。
从20具尸体上肢获取肱骨、桡骨和尺骨的CT三维模型,并生成由几何原语组成的参数模型。原语由描述符参数(直径、角度等)定义,并发现这些描述符之间的相关性。利用这些相关性,实现了一种使用双平面X线片的肱骨半自动重建方法:构建了一个三维个性化参数模型,从中计算临床参数[滑车沟至小头(CTS)轴在骨表面的方向和投影、滑车沟前偏移以及肱骨远端骨骺宽度]。通过与CT扫描比较准确性和再现性来评估该方法。
点到面的平均距离为0.9毫米(2倍均方根误差=2.5毫米)。对于临床参数,平均差异为0.4 - 1.9毫米,角度差异为1.7°至2.3°。除了CTS轴与双髁轴在横平面形成的角度外,所有参数均可重复。重建时间约为5分钟。
所提出的方法能够以极低的辐射剂量获取上肢形态学参数。肱骨的初步体外验证表明,该方法快速且准确,足以在临床日常实践中作为全肘关节置换术前评估的CT扫描替代方法使用。