Department of Medicine, Saint Vincent Hospital, University of Massachusetts, Worcester, USA.
Am J Cardiol. 2012 Jan 15;109(2):174-9. doi: 10.1016/j.amjcard.2011.08.031. Epub 2011 Oct 12.
The current exercise tolerance test (ETT) criteria predominantly assess changes in ST-segment deviation (i.e., a systolic component of the cardiac cycle). Because diastolic dysfunction precedes that of systolic dysfunction during myocardial ischemia and most coronary flow is diastolic, the addition of electrocardiographic markers of diastolic time might improve the ETT sensitivity and specificity for detecting significant coronary artery disease. Among consecutive patients who had an ETT and subsequently underwent coronary angiography, we evaluated the diastolic time by assessing the TP and TQ segments and TP/RR and TQ/RR ratios in each ETT stage. Coronary artery disease was defined angiographically as significant (≥70% lumen occlusion), intermediate (>50% but <70% lumen occlusion), or nonsignificant (≤50% lumen occlusion). Of the 48 study patients, hypertension and hyperlipidemia appeared highly prevalent. TP, TQ, TP/RR, and TQ/RR correlated significantly with RR and changed with each ETT stage. Although TP and TQ were not significantly associated with significant coronary artery disease, TP/RR and TQ/RR proved to be, particularly beyond stage 2. When TQ/RR of ≤0.39 and TP/RR of ≤0.13 were used, their individual sensitivities and specificities were reasonably comparable to that of traditional ETT criteria (79% sensitivity and 44% specificity at our institution). Adding TQ/RR of ≤0.39 and/or TP/RR of ≤0.13 to existing ETT criteria improved its sensitivity to 100% and specificity to 86%. In conclusion, the addition of diastolic time indexes of TP/RR and TQ/RR significantly improved the overall ETT diagnostic value above the guideline-oriented, perhaps "traditional," criteria for the diagnosis of myocardial ischemia. Such parameters should be widely investigated further for clinical accuracy and compatibility.
目前的运动耐量试验(ETT)标准主要评估 ST 段偏移的变化(即,心脏周期的收缩分量)。由于心肌缺血时舒张功能障碍先于收缩功能障碍,并且大多数冠状动脉血流是舒张期的,因此添加心电图舒张时间标志物可能会提高 ETT 检测显著冠状动脉疾病的敏感性和特异性。在连续接受 ETT 并随后进行冠状动脉造影的患者中,我们通过评估每个 ETT 阶段的 TP 和 TQ 段以及 TP/RR 和 TQ/RR 比值来评估舒张时间。冠状动脉疾病定义为造影检查有意义(≥70%管腔闭塞)、中度(>50%但<70%管腔闭塞)或无意义(≤50%管腔闭塞)。在 48 例研究患者中,高血压和高血脂似乎非常普遍。TP、TQ、TP/RR 和 TQ/RR 与 RR 显著相关,并随 ETT 阶段变化而变化。尽管 TP 和 TQ 与显著冠状动脉疾病无显著相关性,但 TP/RR 和 TQ/RR 则与之相关,特别是在 2 期之后。当 TQ/RR≤0.39 和 TP/RR≤0.13 时,它们的个体敏感性和特异性与传统 ETT 标准相当(我们机构的敏感性为 79%,特异性为 44%)。将 TQ/RR≤0.39 和/或 TP/RR≤0.13 添加到现有的 ETT 标准中可将其敏感性提高到 100%,特异性提高到 86%。总之,添加 TP/RR 和 TQ/RR 的舒张时间指数可显著提高整体 ETT 诊断价值,超过了指南导向的、可能是“传统的”心肌缺血诊断标准。这些参数应该进一步广泛研究其临床准确性和兼容性。