Chan S L, Reggiardo Z, Daniel T M, Girling D J, Mitchison D A
Wanchai Chest Clinic, Hong Kong.
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1990 Aug;142(2):385-9. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm/142.2.385.
Hemagglutination tests with three glycolipid antigens, A1, B1, and C, and ELISA with antigen 5 were done on serum from Chinese patients with pulmonary tuberculosis and from normal subjects in Hong Kong. Tests with all four antigens were of similar efficiency, giving positive results in 30 to 52% of 88 smear-positive patients, in 16 to 22% of 37 smear-negative, culture-positive patients, in 5 to 13% of 76 culture-negative patients with radiologically active disease, in 5 to 11% of 217 culture-negative patients with inactive disease, and in 1 to 4% of 140 normal subjects. If tests were combined so that an overall positive was scored when all tests were positive, there was worse discrimination between patients and normal subjects; however, as suggested by the poor correlation between the results with pairs of the tests, better discrimination was obtained if an overall positive was scored when any of the tests was positive. A positive result in any of the four tests was found in 22% of all cases, including 58% of smear-positive patients, 32% of smear-negative, culture-positive patients, and 0.7% of normal subjects.
对中国肺结核患者及香港正常受试者的血清进行了三项糖脂抗原(A1、B1和C)的血凝试验以及抗原5的酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)。使用这四种抗原进行的检测效率相似,在88例涂片阳性患者中有30%至52%呈阳性结果,在37例涂片阴性但培养阳性的患者中有16%至22%呈阳性结果,在76例有放射学活动性疾病的培养阴性患者中有5%至13%呈阳性结果,在217例无活动性疾病的培养阴性患者中有5%至11%呈阳性结果,在140例正常受试者中有1%至4%呈阳性结果。如果将检测结果合并,使得所有检测均为阳性时记为总体阳性,则患者与正常受试者之间的区分度更差;然而,正如两对检测结果之间的低相关性所表明的那样,如果任何一项检测为阳性时记为总体阳性,则能获得更好的区分度。在所有病例中,22%的病例四项检测中的任何一项呈阳性结果,其中包括58%的涂片阳性患者、32%的涂片阴性但培养阳性的患者以及0.7%的正常受试者。