a Aker University Hospital.
Psychother Res. 2005 Jul;15(3):304-15. doi: 10.1080/10503300500091835.
Abstract There are few empirical outcome studies of psychotherapies with women exposed to childhood sexual abuse (CSA). The aims of this review were to examine designs and outcomes of such studies. Several publication databases were searched for studies based on defined inclusion criteria. Meta-analysis with weighted standardized effect sizes was performed on 12 controlled studies, and unweighted effect sizes were calculated for pre-post treatment gains of 11 noncontrolled studies. Persistence of gains from posttreatment to follow-up was mostly found in 9 follow-up studies. Fifteen studies examined short-term group (≤20 sessions) psychotherapies. All studies examined treatment effectiveness, and they mostly had a low quality of design. For posttreatment gains, mean total effect size was .63 in controlled studies. Effect sizes for noncontrolled studies were somewhat higher. Minimal changes from posttreatment to follow-up were observed. Multicenter studies with better design are needed, but the theoretical underpinnings for specific therapies in women with CSA should first be reexamined.
摘要 针对遭受过儿童期性虐待 (CSA) 的女性,目前鲜见心理疗法的实证研究结果。本综述旨在考察此类研究的设计和结果。基于明确的纳入标准,检索了多个出版数据库,以寻找相关研究。对 12 项对照研究进行了加权标准化效应量的荟萃分析,并对 11 项非对照研究的治疗前后增益进行了未加权效应量的计算。在 9 项随访研究中,大多数研究发现从治疗后到随访时增益的持续性。15 项研究检验了短期团体(≤20 次)心理疗法。所有研究都检验了治疗效果,且它们的设计质量大多较低。对于治疗后增益,对照研究的平均总效应量为.63。非对照研究的效应量稍高一些。从治疗后到随访时,观察到的变化最小。需要进行具有更好设计的多中心研究,但首先应重新审视 CSA 女性特定治疗方法的理论基础。