Mackie Andrew S, Rempel Gwen R, Rankin Kathryn N, Nicholas David, Magill-Evans Joyce
Division of Cardiology, Department of Pediatrics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Cardiol Young. 2012 Jun;22(3):307-15. doi: 10.1017/S104795111100148X. Epub 2011 Oct 21.
To identify risk factors for loss to cardiology follow-up among children and young adults with congenital heart disease.
We used a matched case-control design. Cases were born before January, 2001 with moderate or complex congenital heart disease and were previously followed up in the paediatric or adult cardiology clinic, but not seen for 3 years or longer. Controls had been seen within 3 years. Controls were matched 3:1 to cases by year of birth and congenital heart disease lesion. Medical records were reviewed for potential risk factors for loss to follow-up. A subset of cases and controls participated in recorded telephone interviews.
A total of 74 cases (66% male) were compared with 222 controls (61% male). A history of missed cardiology appointments was predictive of loss to follow-up for 3 years or longer (odds ratio 13.0, 95% confidence interval 3.3-51.7). Variables protective from loss to follow-up were higher family income (odds ratio 0.87 per $10,000 increase, 0.77-0.98), cardiac catheterisation within 5 years (odds ratio 0.2, 95% confidence interval 0.1-0.6), and chart documentation of the need for cardiology follow-up (odds ratio 0.4, 95% confidence interval 0.2-0.8). Cases lacked awareness of the importance of follow-up and identified primary care physicians as their primary source of information about the heart, rather than cardiologists. Unlike cases, controls had methods to remember appointments.
A history of one or more missed cardiology appointments predicted loss to follow-up for 3 or more years, as did lack of awareness of the need for follow-up. Higher family income, recent catheterisations, and medical record documentation of the need for follow-up were protective.
确定先天性心脏病儿童和青年成人心脏病随访失访的危险因素。
我们采用匹配病例对照设计。病例为2001年1月前出生的患有中度或复杂性先天性心脏病的患者,此前在儿科或成人心脏病诊所接受随访,但3年或更长时间未就诊。对照在3年内就诊过。对照按出生年份和先天性心脏病病变与病例以3:1的比例匹配。查阅病历以寻找随访失访的潜在危险因素。一部分病例和对照参与了电话录音访谈。
共74例病例(66%为男性)与222例对照(61%为男性)进行比较。有错过心脏病预约的病史可预测3年或更长时间的随访失访(比值比13.0,95%置信区间3.3 - 51.7)。防止随访失访的变量包括家庭收入较高(每增加10,000美元比值比0.87,0.77 - 0.98)、5年内进行心导管检查(比值比0.2,95%置信区间0.1 - 0.6)以及病历记录有心脏病随访需求(比值比0.4,95%置信区间0.2 - 0.8)。病例缺乏对随访重要性的认识,将初级保健医生视为其心脏信息的主要来源,而非心脏病专家。与病例不同,对照有记住预约的方法。
有一次或多次错过心脏病预约的病史以及缺乏对随访需求的认识可预测3年或更长时间的随访失访。家庭收入较高、近期进行心导管检查以及病历记录有随访需求具有保护作用。