Medica Research Institute, Minnetonka, MN 55305, USA.
Br J Nutr. 2012 Jul;108(2):349-56. doi: 10.1017/S0007114511005435. Epub 2011 Oct 13.
The relationship between dietary intake and obesity is complex, and dietary pattern analysis may offer new insight. We examined associations between dietary patterns identified in a diverse cohort of adolescents and weight status cross-sectionally and over a 5-year period. Project EAT (Eating Among Teens) (Time 1) collected data on 4746 middle (younger cohort) and high school (older cohort) students in 1998-9. EAT-II (Time 2) resurveyed 2516 of the original cohort in 2003-4. All analyses were run separately by age cohort and sex. The relationship between dietary patterns identified previously (vegetable, fruit, vegetable & fruit, starchy food, sweet & salty snack food, and fast food) and weight status was examined using logistic regression. All analyses were adjusted for socioeconomic status, race/ethnicity and activity level (longitudinal analyses were also adjusted for baseline weight status). In cross-sectional analyses, higher adherence to dietary patterns loading heavily on vegetables was associated with lower risk of overweight/obese weight status in older and younger girls, whereas higher adherence to a 'sweet & salty snack food' pattern was associated with lower risk in older and younger boys. These associations were found prospectively in older boys and girls, but were no longer significant in analyses adjusting for baseline weight status. We did not find consistent or intuitive associations between dietary patterns and weight status. Identified patterns may not capture the elements of diet that are truly important in determining adolescent weight, or diet may not be the primary driver in determining weight status at this age. Methodological difficulties in assessing diet must also be taken into consideration.
饮食摄入与肥胖之间的关系很复杂,而饮食模式分析可能会提供新的见解。我们研究了在一个多样化的青少年队列中确定的饮食模式与体重状况之间的横断面和 5 年期间的关联。EAT 项目(青少年饮食)(时间 1)于 1998-9 年收集了 4746 名中学生(年轻队列)和高中生(年长队列)的数据。EAT-II(时间 2)在 2003-4 年重新调查了原始队列中的 2516 名学生。所有分析均按年龄队列和性别分别进行。使用逻辑回归检查先前确定的饮食模式(蔬菜、水果、蔬菜和水果、淀粉类食物、甜咸零食和快餐)与体重状况之间的关系。所有分析均调整了社会经济地位、种族/民族和活动水平(纵向分析还调整了基线体重状况)。在横断面分析中,蔬菜摄入量较高的饮食模式与超重/肥胖体重状况的风险降低相关,这与年长和年轻女孩有关,而较高的“甜咸零食”模式的饮食模式与年长和年轻男孩的风险降低有关。这些关联在年长男孩和女孩的前瞻性分析中发现,但在调整基线体重状况的分析中不再显著。我们没有发现饮食模式和体重状况之间一致或直观的关联。确定的模式可能无法捕捉到真正决定青少年体重的饮食要素,或者饮食可能不是这个年龄段决定体重状况的主要因素。评估饮食的方法学困难也必须加以考虑。