Kreuzer Stefan, Leffers Kevin
Memorial Bone and Joint Research Foundation, Houston, Texas 77043, USA.
Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis. 2011;69 Suppl 1:S52-5.
The incorporation of computer navigation in total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been much slower than for total knee arthroplasty (TKA). One reason for this is that a majority of THAs are performed with the patient in the lateral position through a posterior or lateral approach, making the tracker placement and the registration process cumbersome. In the direct anterior approach, the patient is in the supine position, which accommodates pelvic tracker placement and markedly facilitates the registration process. At our institution, we use the direct anterior approach and computer navigation on all of our primary THAs. We hypothesized that computer navigation improves cup placement without increasing operative time.
This was a retrospective study comparing a consecutive series of 150 computer navigated THAs to a consecutive series of 150 non-navigated hips. The two groups were similarly matched by age, gender, and body mass index. Postoperative anteroposterior pelvic radiographs and operative times were analyzed.
The navigation group mean cup inclination was 41° (range, 32° to 54°), compared to 36° (range, 19° to 52°) for the non-navigated group. The mean surgical time for the navigation group was 56 minutes (range, 34 to 91 minutes) and 61 minutes (range, 33 to 119 minutes) for the non-navigated group.
The results suggest that computer navigation is easy to incorporate when utilizing a direct anterior approach and in our series shortens the operative time. The accuracy and precision of cup angle placement is comparable to our non-navigated method but appears to be slightly improved with computer navigation. Although more work is needed for progress with this promising technology, we believe that incorporating computer navigation for hip arthroplasties in the supine position is straightforward and of great value.
计算机导航在全髋关节置换术(THA)中的应用比在全膝关节置换术(TKA)中要慢得多。原因之一是,大多数全髋关节置换术是通过后侧或外侧入路在患者侧卧位下进行的,这使得追踪器放置和注册过程繁琐。在直接前路手术中,患者处于仰卧位,便于骨盆追踪器放置并显著简化注册过程。在我们机构,我们对所有初次全髋关节置换术都采用直接前路和计算机导航。我们假设计算机导航可改善髋臼放置且不增加手术时间。
这是一项回顾性研究,将连续的150例计算机导航全髋关节置换术与连续的150例非导航髋关节进行比较。两组在年龄、性别和体重指数方面匹配。分析术后前后位骨盆X线片和手术时间。
导航组髋臼平均倾斜度为41°(范围32°至54°),非导航组为36°(范围19°至52°)。导航组平均手术时间为56分钟(范围34至91分钟),非导航组为61分钟(范围33至119分钟)。
结果表明,在采用直接前路时,计算机导航易于应用,且在我们的系列研究中缩短了手术时间。髋臼角度放置的准确性和精确性与我们的非导航方法相当,但计算机导航似乎略有改善。尽管这项有前景的技术还需要更多工作来推进,但我们认为在仰卧位髋关节置换术中应用计算机导航简单易行且具有很大价值。