Kummervold Per Egil, Johnsen Jan-Are K
Norwegian Centre for Integrated Care and Telemedicine, University Hospital of North Norway HF, Tromsø, Norway.
J Med Internet Res. 2011 Nov 1;13(4):e79. doi: 10.2196/jmir.1583.
Patients want to use electronic communication to access health services more easily. Health authorities in several countries see this as a way to improve health care. Physicians appear to have conflicting opinions regarding the suitability of electronic communication in clinical settings.
The aim of our study was to measure how long it actually takes physicians to answer questions from patients through an electronic communication channel, and whether some of the questions are especially time consuming.
We monitored electronic patient-physician communication. A total of 1113 messages from 14 participating physicians from 7 medical offices were analyzed. The length of questions and answers, and the time physicians spent answering the questions were recorded and analyzed.
Physicians spent an average of 2.3 minutes (median 2 minutes) answering questions from patients. The patients' questions had an average length of 507.1 characters (95% CI 487.4-526.9, SD 336.2), while physicians' answers averaged 119.9 characters (95% CI 189.8-210.0, SD 172.6). The results show that the influence of patient question length on time spent responding was negligible. For the shortest 25% of the questions the answer time was 2.1 minutes (95% CI 1.9-2.3), while it was 2.4 minutes (95% CI 2.2-2.7) for the longest 25%. Even extremely long questions had a minimal impact on the time spent answering them. A threefold increase in question length from patients resulted in only an 18% increase in physician response time.
The study shows the potential clinical usefulness of electronic communication between patients and health care services by demonstrating the potential for saving time.
患者希望通过电子通信更便捷地获取医疗服务。多个国家的卫生当局将此视为改善医疗保健的一种方式。对于电子通信在临床环境中的适用性,医生们似乎存在相互矛盾的观点。
我们研究的目的是衡量医生通过电子通信渠道回答患者问题实际所需的时间,以及是否有些问题特别耗时。
我们监测了患者与医生之间的电子通信。对来自7个医疗办公室的14名参与医生的1113条信息进行了分析。记录并分析了问题和答案的长度,以及医生回答问题所花费的时间。
医生回答患者问题平均花费2.3分钟(中位数为2分钟)。患者问题的平均长度为507.1个字符(95%置信区间487.4 - 526.9,标准差336.2),而医生的回答平均为119.9个字符(95%置信区间189.8 - 210.0,标准差172.6)。结果表明,患者问题长度对回答时间的影响可忽略不计。对于最短的25%的问题,回答时间为2.1分钟(95%置信区间1.9 - 2.3),而对于最长的25%的问题,回答时间为2.4分钟(95%置信区间2.2 - 2.7)。即使是极长的问题对回答时间的影响也微乎其微。患者问题长度增加两倍,医生的回答时间仅增加18%。
该研究通过展示节省时间的潜力,表明了患者与医疗服务之间电子通信在临床上的潜在实用性。