Gulbrandsen Pål, Østbye Truls, Lyna Pauline, Dolor Rowena J, Tulsky James A, Alexander Stewart C, Pollak Kathryn I
HØH, Research Centre, Akershus University Hospital, Løkog, Norway, and Institute of Clinical Medicine, University of Oslo.
Fam Med. 2012 Mar;44(3):183-8.
Little is known about how patients and physicians perceive time and the extent to which they perceive the physician being rushed during encounters. One aim of this paper is to examine whether patient and physician characteristics and physician communication influence patient perception of the duration of the encounter and their perception of physicians being rushed. Another aim is to examine the relationship between patient and physician perceptions of physicians feeling rushed.
We audiorecorded 461 encounters of overweight or obese patients with 40 primary care physicians and included 320 encounters in which weight was discussed. We calculated time spent with physician and coded all communication about weight using the Motivational Interview Treatment Integrity scale (MITI). Patients completed post-visit questionnaires in which they reported the estimated duration of the encounter and how rushed they thought the physician was during the encounter. Physicians reported how rushed they felt.
Patients estimated encounters to be longer than they actually were by an average of 2.6 minutes (SD=11.0). When physicians used reflective statements when discussing weight, patients estimated the encounter to be shorter than when physicians did not use reflective statements (1.17 versus 4.56 minutes more than actual duration). Whites perceived the encounter as shorter than African Americans (1.45 versus 4.28 minutes more than actual duration). Physicians felt rushed in 66% of visits; however, most patients did not perceive this. Internists were perceived to be more rushed than family physicians.
There is wide variation in patients' ability to estimate the length of time they spend with their physician. Some physician and patient characteristics were related to patient perceptions of the length of the encounter. Reflective statements might lead patients to perceive encounters as shorter. Physicians, especially family physicians, appear able to conceal that they are feeling rushed.
关于患者和医生如何看待时间,以及他们在诊疗过程中感受到医生匆忙的程度,目前所知甚少。本文的一个目的是研究患者和医生的特征以及医生的沟通方式是否会影响患者对诊疗时长的感知,以及他们对医生匆忙程度的感知。另一个目的是研究患者和医生对医生匆忙程度的感知之间的关系。
我们对461名超重或肥胖患者与40名初级保健医生的诊疗过程进行了录音,其中320次诊疗讨论了体重问题。我们计算了与医生相处的时间,并使用动机性访谈治疗完整性量表(MITI)对所有关于体重的沟通进行编码。患者在就诊后完成问卷调查,报告他们估计的诊疗时长以及他们认为医生在诊疗过程中有多匆忙。医生报告了他们自己感觉有多匆忙。
患者估计的诊疗时长比实际时长平均长2.6分钟(标准差=11.0)。当医生在讨论体重时使用反思性陈述时,患者估计的诊疗时长比医生不使用反思性陈述时短(比实际时长分别多1.17分钟和4.56分钟)。白人认为诊疗时长比非裔美国人短(比实际时长分别多1.45分钟和4.28分钟)。66%的就诊中医生感觉匆忙;然而,大多数患者并未察觉到这一点。内科医生比家庭医生更被认为匆忙。
患者估计与医生相处时长的能力差异很大。一些医生和患者的特征与患者对诊疗时长的感知有关。反思性陈述可能会使患者觉得诊疗时长更短。医生,尤其是家庭医生,似乎能够掩饰他们感到匆忙的情绪。