Kahn V, Fohlen A, Pelage J-P
Service de radiologie, CHU de Caen, avenue de La-Côte-de-Nacre, 14033 Caen cedex 09, France.
J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris). 2011 Dec;40(8):918-27. doi: 10.1016/j.jgyn.2011.09.030. Epub 2011 Nov 16.
Uterine artery embolization using non spherical PVA particles or calibrated trisacryl microspheres above 500 μm is effective to treat menorrhagia, bulk-related symptoms and pelvic pain in more than 90% of cases in the short-term. In the long-term, embolization is effective in 75% of cases at 5-7 years. At 6 months, uterine volume reduction and dominant fibroid volume reduction varies between 30-60% and 50-80% respectively. During hospital stay, the complication rate is 3%. Secondary hysterectomy for complication is less than 2% at 3 months. Definitive amenorrhea is reported in less than 5% of cases in women of less than 45 years of age. No significant impact of embolization on hormonal function has been reported in women less than 45 years with normal baseline function. Secondary hysterectomy for clinical failure or recurrence is reported in 14-28% of cases at 5 years. Non-spherical PVA particles are associated with more microcatheter occlusion than trisacryl microspheres. No difference between PVA particles and trisacryl microspheres was found in terms of post-embolization pain or analgesic doses. PVA microspheres (Contour SE et Bead Block) are associated with lower clinical success and lower fibroid devascularization using MRI than trisacryl microspheres. No difference between PVA particles and trisacryl microspheres was found in terms of clinical efficacy, uterine volume reduction and complication rate. Randomized studies comparing embolization to hysterectomy demonstrate that reinterventions are more frequently performed after embolization. Secondary hysterectomy is performed in 13 to 24% of cases at 2 years and in up to 28% of cases at 5 years. Hospital stay, duration of recovery and time off work are shorter after embolization compared to hysterectomy. Embolization is cheaper than hysterectomy at 12 and 24 months even taking into consideration the additional costs of imaging and reinterventions. Randomized studies comparing embolization to myomectomy demonstrate that in the short- and mid-term there is no difference in terms of control of menorrhagia and bulk-related symptoms. Uterine volume reduction and quality of life were not different at 6 months. Periprocedural and 30-day complication rates are not different. At 6 months, the rate of complications is higher after myomectomy. Reinterventions are more frequent after embolization compared to myomectomy. Hospital stay, duration of recovery and time off work are shorter after embolization compared to myomectomy. Embolization should be considered with caution in pregnancy-seeking women since there is still a lack of good quality data available in the specific group of patients. FSH level is more frequently elevated after embolization compared to myomectomy. Pregnancy rate and term pregnancy rate are higher after myomectomy compared to embolization. Spontaneous abortion is more frequent after embolization than after myomectomy. There is no difference between embolization and myomectomy for the rates of pre-term delivery, cesarean section, post-partum hemorrhage, pre-eclampsia or intra-uterine growth retardation. Embolization performed before myomectomy (preoperative or combined procedures) can be discussed for an individual patient but there is not enough data to support its routine use.
使用非球形聚乙烯醇(PVA)颗粒或直径大于500μm的校准三丙烯酸微球进行子宫动脉栓塞术,在短期内对90%以上的病例治疗月经过多、与肌瘤体积相关的症状及盆腔疼痛有效。长期来看,在5至7年时栓塞术对75%的病例有效。6个月时,子宫体积缩小和主要肌瘤体积缩小分别在30%至60%和50%至80%之间。住院期间,并发症发生率为3%。3个月时因并发症行子宫切除术的比例低于2%。45岁以下女性中,不到5%的病例出现永久性闭经。对于基线功能正常的45岁以下女性,未报告栓塞术对激素功能有显著影响。5年时,14%至28%的病例因临床失败或复发而行子宫切除术。与三丙烯酸微球相比,非球形PVA颗粒导致微导管堵塞的情况更多。在栓塞后疼痛或止痛药物剂量方面,未发现PVA颗粒与三丙烯酸微球有差异。PVA微球(Contour SE和Bead Block)与三丙烯酸微球相比,临床成功率较低,且磁共振成像显示肌瘤去血管化程度较低。在临床疗效、子宫体积缩小和并发症发生率方面,未发现PVA颗粒与三丙烯酸微球有差异。比较栓塞术与子宫切除术的随机研究表明,栓塞术后再次干预更为频繁。2年时,13%至24%的病例行子宫切除术,5年时高达28%。与子宫切除术相比,栓塞术后住院时间、恢复时间和误工时间更短。即使考虑到影像学检查和再次干预的额外费用,栓塞术在12个月和24个月时比子宫切除术更便宜。比较栓塞术与肌瘤切除术的随机研究表明,在短期和中期,月经过多及与肌瘤体积相关症状的控制方面无差异。6个月时子宫体积缩小和生活质量无差异。围手术期和30天并发症发生率无差异。6个月时,肌瘤切除术后并发症发生率更高。与肌瘤切除术相比,栓塞术后再次干预更为频繁。与肌瘤切除术相比,栓塞术后住院时间、恢复时间和误工时间更短。对于有妊娠意愿的女性,应谨慎考虑栓塞术,因为该特定患者群体仍缺乏高质量数据。与肌瘤切除术相比,栓塞术后促卵泡激素(FSH)水平更常升高。与栓塞术相比,肌瘤切除术后妊娠率和足月妊娠率更高。栓塞术后自然流产比肌瘤切除术后更频繁。在早产、剖宫产、产后出血、先兆子痫或胎儿宫内生长受限的发生率方面,栓塞术与肌瘤切除术无差异。对于个别患者,可以讨论在肌瘤切除术之前进行栓塞术(术前或联合手术),但没有足够的数据支持其常规使用。