Department of Biology, University of Hildesheim, Marienburger Platz 22, 31141 Hildesheim, Germany.
Sci Total Environ. 2012 Jan 1;414:686-95. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2011.10.041. Epub 2011 Dec 1.
Wild deer have been recommended as bioindicators of fluoride pollution. We compared bone fluoride concentrations and prevalence and severity of dental fluorosis in free-ranging European roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) and red deer (Cervus elaphus) from five counties in the northwestern part of the Czech Republic that had been collected by hunters and whose mandibles were presented at trophy exhibitions in the years 1996/1997 ("early period") and 2009 ("late period"). Data on atmospheric fluoride deposition suggested that the deer from the early period had been exposed to markedly higher fluoride levels than those from the late period. We therefore predicted a decline in skeletal fluoride levels and prevalence of dental fluorosis for both species from the early to the late period. Fluoride concentrations were determined in the coronoid process of the mandible, and assessment of dental fluorosis was performed on the permanent cheek teeth. A pronounced drop in fluoride concentrations from the early period (roe deer (n = 157), median: 3147 mg F(-)/kg of dry bone; red deer (n = 127), median: 1263 mg F(-)/kg of dry bone) to the late period (roe deer (n = 117), median: 350 mg F(-)/kg of dry bone; red deer (n = 72), median: 288 mg F(-)/kg of dry bone) was recorded. Prevalence of dental fluorosis also markedly declined from the early to the late period (roe deer: from 93% to 12%, red deer: from 87% to 28%). The reduction of fluoride deposition in the study area and, in consequence, fluoride exposure of the resident deer populations, is attributed largely to the implementation of emission control devices in the brown coal-fired power plants located in North Bohemia from the mid 1990s onwards. The findings of the present study demonstrate that wild deer are well suited for monitoring temporal changes in fluoride pollution of their habitats.
野生鹿已被推荐为氟污染的生物指标。我们比较了来自捷克西北部五个县的自由放养的欧洲狍(Capreolus capreolus)和马鹿(Cervus elaphus)的骨氟浓度以及牙齿氟斑的流行率和严重程度,这些鹿是由猎人收集的,其下颚骨在 1996/1997 年(“早期”)和 2009 年(“晚期”)的奖杯展览中展出。大气氟沉积的数据表明,早期的鹿暴露于明显更高水平的氟化物,比晚期的鹿更高。因此,我们预测两种物种的骨骼氟化物水平和牙齿氟斑的流行率从早期到晚期都会下降。氟化物浓度在下颚骨的冠状突中测定,牙齿氟斑的评估在恒齿上进行。从早期(狍(n = 157),中位数:3147 mg F(-)/ kg干骨;马鹿(n = 127),中位数:1263 mg F(-)/ kg干骨)到晚期(狍(n = 117),中位数:350 mg F(-)/ kg干骨;马鹿(n = 72),中位数:288 mg F(-)/ kg干骨),氟化物浓度明显下降。牙齿氟斑的流行率也从早期到晚期显著下降(狍:从 93%降至 12%,马鹿:从 87%降至 28%)。研究区域内氟化物沉积的减少,以及由此导致的居住鹿群的氟暴露,主要归因于自 20 世纪 90 年代中期以来在北波希米亚的褐煤火力发电厂实施的排放控制装置。本研究的结果表明,野生鹿非常适合监测其栖息地氟污染的时间变化。