Botanical Garden, Department of Biology, Università degli Studi di Milano, Via Celoria 26, 20133 Milan, Italy.
Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2012 Feb;62(2):736-47. doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2011.11.015. Epub 2011 Nov 28.
Wild grapes are woody climbers, found mostly in temperate regions of the northern hemisphere, comprising the genus Vitis. Despite its importance, the evolutionary history of Vitis is still contentious. Past studies have led to conflicting hypotheses about the phylogeny, speciation events, and biogeographic history of the genus. Here we investigate the evolutionary history of Vitis using data from four chloroplast spacers (trnH-psbA, trnK-rps16, trnF-nahJ, and rpl32-trnL) and the nuclear gene RPB2-I, and we explore mechanisms that could have shaped the observed distribution of current species. Maximum likelihood and Bayesian analyses provided similar results, strongly supporting the presence of two subgenera and suggesting a species clustering within subgenus Vitis that mainly mirrors the disjunction between the Old and New World. Vitis vinifera subsp. sylvestris was found to be sister to the Asian species while three major clades were found in the American species. A network approach confirmed the main geographic groups and highlighted different chloroplast haplotype patterns between Asian and American species. Molecular dating analysis provided the time boundaries to discuss our results. Our study shows wild grape diversification to be a continuous and complex process that concerned the Tertiary as well as the Quaternary, most likely involving both geographical and climatic forces. Local variations in extent and timing of these forces were discussed based on observed differences between groups. In the context of the Tertiary-Quaternary debate, we provide evidence in favor of the "continuous hypothesis" to explain present diversity. Finally, two directions for future research are highlighted: (i) was the earliest grape American or Asian? and (ii) are all modern grape species real?
野生葡萄是木质藤本植物,主要分布在北半球温带地区,包括葡萄属(Vitis)。尽管其重要性不言而喻,但葡萄属的进化历史仍存在争议。过去的研究导致了关于其系统发育、物种形成事件和生物地理历史的假说相互矛盾。在这里,我们使用来自四个叶绿体间隔区(trnH-psbA、trnK-rps16、trnF-nahJ 和 rpl32-trnL)和核基因 RPB2-I 的数据来研究葡萄属的进化历史,并探索可能影响当前物种分布的机制。最大似然法和贝叶斯分析法得到了相似的结果,强烈支持两个亚属的存在,并表明亚属内的物种聚类主要反映了旧世界和新世界的分离。葡萄属野生亚种 sylvestris 与亚洲物种关系最为密切,而美洲物种则分为三个主要分支。网络分析方法证实了主要的地理群体,并突出了亚洲和美洲物种之间不同的叶绿体单倍型模式。分子定年分析提供了讨论结果的时间界限。我们的研究表明,野生葡萄的多样化是一个连续而复杂的过程,涉及第三纪和第四纪,很可能涉及地理和气候因素。根据观察到的群体间差异,讨论了这些因素在范围和时间上的局部变化。在第三纪-第四纪争论的背景下,我们提供了支持“连续假说”的证据,以解释目前的多样性。最后,强调了未来研究的两个方向:(i)最早的葡萄是美洲还是亚洲?(ii)所有现代葡萄物种都是真实存在的吗?