Dixon Peter, McAnsh Scott, Read Lenore
Department of Psychology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Can J Exp Psychol. 2012 Mar;66(1):1-17. doi: 10.1037/a0026192. Epub 2011 Dec 12.
The task in the present experiments was to reach out and grasp a novel object that afforded two possible grips. Different versions of the object were created that biased subjects to use one grip or the other. The dependent variable was the repetition effect, the tendency to repeat the grip that was used on the previous trial. In Experiment 1, two qualitatively different objects were used, and it was found that the repetition effect was specific to the object being grasped: There was much less tendency to use the same grip as the previous trial if the object being grasped was different. Moreover, the effect lasted over intervening trials and was even present with more than five intervening trials. In Experiment 2, the global context was manipulated, so that in some blocks one grip was much more likely than the other. However, this manipulation had little effect on the choice of grip and did not interact with the repetition effect. In Experiment 3, the hand used to grasp the object was manipulated, and there was little change in the repetition effect. Thus, a grip was more likely to be used if it was used on the previous trial, regardless of whether the previous grasp was performed with the left or right hand. In Experiment 4, a similar result was found for a manipulation of object location and orientation. Our interpretation of these results is that subjects prepare for an action by retrieving action features from memory, and that the object to be grasped provides a critical cue for that memory retrieval. In this view, the repetition effect is essentially a memory recency effect.
在当前实验中的任务是伸手去抓握一个有两种抓握方式的新物体。创建了该物体的不同版本,使受试者倾向于使用其中一种抓握方式。因变量是重复效应,即重复前一次试验中使用的抓握方式的倾向。在实验1中,使用了两种性质不同的物体,结果发现重复效应是特定于所抓握的物体的:如果所抓握的物体不同,那么使用与前一次试验相同抓握方式的倾向就会小得多。此外,这种效应在中间试验中持续存在,甚至在超过五次中间试验时也存在。在实验2中,对整体情境进行了操控,使得在某些组试验中,一种抓握方式比另一种更有可能被使用。然而,这种操控对抓握方式的选择影响很小,并且与重复效应没有相互作用。在实验3中,对抓握物体所使用的手进行了操控,重复效应几乎没有变化。因此,如果前一次试验中使用了某种抓握方式,那么无论前一次抓握是用左手还是右手进行的,这种抓握方式都更有可能被再次使用。在实验4中,对于物体位置和方向的操控也得到了类似的结果。我们对这些结果的解释是,受试者通过从记忆中检索动作特征来为行动做准备,并且要抓握的物体为该记忆检索提供了关键线索。按照这种观点,重复效应本质上是一种记忆近因效应。