Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, Utrecht University, Post Box 80140, 3508 TC Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Psychol Health. 2012;27(8):956-70. doi: 10.1080/08870446.2011.635303. Epub 2011 Dec 12.
Previous research established that norms describing the behaviour of a majority (e.g. 'many people consume too much alcohol') can have ironic and unwanted effects on health behaviour. To date, no research has addressed the effects of minority descriptive norms (e.g. 'only few people use sunscreen'), while such minority norms are frequently communicated to the public. The current studies investigate the effects of minority and majority norms on intended and actual fruit intake. University students received either minority or majority normative information describing fruit intake behaviour of a referent group. Identification strength with this referent group was measured (Study 1) or manipulated (Study 2). Results showed that, compared to majority norms, minority norms negatively affected fruit intake when participants strongly identify with the referent group. Moreover, absolute negative (minority norm) and positive (majority norm) effects of one-third portion of fruit were found compared to a no-norm condition. Since minority norms are often communicated with the intention of alarming people regarding their low engagement in health protective behaviour, the potential ironic effects of these minority norms should be taken into account when presenting such information to the public.
先前的研究已经证实,描述多数人行为的规范(例如“许多人饮酒过量”)可能会对健康行为产生讽刺和意外的影响。迄今为止,还没有研究涉及少数描述性规范(例如“只有少数人使用防晒霜”)的影响,而这些少数规范经常向公众传播。本研究旨在调查少数和多数规范对预期和实际水果摄入量的影响。研究对象收到了描述参照群体水果摄入量行为的少数或多数规范信息。在研究 1 中测量了与参照群体的认同强度,在研究 2 中则对其进行了操纵。结果表明,与多数规范相比,当参与者强烈认同参照群体时,少数规范会对水果摄入量产生负面影响。此外,与无规范条件相比,水果摄入量的绝对负向(少数规范)和正向(多数规范)影响为三分之一部分。由于少数规范通常是为了引起人们对其低参与健康保护行为的关注而传达的,因此在向公众传达此类信息时,应考虑到这些少数规范可能产生的讽刺效果。