Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Curr Opin Anaesthesiol. 2012 Apr;25(2):221-5. doi: 10.1097/ACO.0b013e32834f00ec.
The current economic climate has put pressure on healthcare systems and providers, including anesthesiologists, to minimize costs without sacrificing patient safety. In this review, we discuss costs associated with anesthesia care, including medications and intraoperative monitoring, and suggest ways to reduce wastes and overall expenditure.
Significant amount, perhaps 20-50%, of drugs drawn up are never used but discarded as whole ampoules or vials. There has been a progressive shift to using more expensive inhalational agents and total intravenous anesthesia in the last 10 years. Highest drug costs are associated with total intravenous anesthesia protocols, which are five to 10 times more expensive than administering sevoflurane or desflurane with premedication using antiemetics. Among the inhalational agents, usage costs of sevoflurane and desflurane are 10 and 25 times, respectively, that of isoflurane. Bispectral index monitoring, which requires use of an expensive proprietary electrode is no better, perhaps even less effective, than titration of inhalational agents using end tidal anesthetic concentration to monitor depth of anesthesia and prevent intraoperative awareness.
Anesthesia medications comprise a significant proportion of hospital pharmacy budgets. Average anesthesia-related cost reductions of US$ 13-30 per cases multiplied by 25 million anesthetics administered annually in the USA has the potential to yield savings of US$ 350-750 million. Bispectral index monitoring during inhalational anesthesia adds to the cost without providing any benefit.
当前的经济环境给医疗保健系统和医疗服务提供者(包括麻醉师)带来了压力,他们需要在不影响患者安全的情况下尽量降低成本。在本次综述中,我们讨论了与麻醉护理相关的成本,包括药物和术中监测,并提出了减少浪费和总体支出的方法。
在过去的 10 年中,大约有 20%-50%的配制药物从未使用过,而是作为整支安瓿或小瓶被丢弃。人们越来越倾向于使用更昂贵的吸入性麻醉剂和全静脉麻醉。总静脉麻醉方案的药物成本最高,其费用是给予预用药的七氟醚或地氟醚和使用止吐药的费用的五到十倍。在吸入性麻醉剂中,七氟醚和地氟醚的使用成本分别是异氟醚的 10 倍和 25 倍。需要使用昂贵专利电极的脑电双频指数监测,在监测麻醉深度和预防术中知晓方面,与根据呼气末麻醉浓度滴定吸入性麻醉剂的效果一样,甚至可能效果更差。
麻醉药物占医院药房预算的很大一部分。美国每年实施 2500 万例麻醉,若将平均每次麻醉相关成本降低 13-30 美元,每年可节省 3.5-7.5 亿美元。在吸入性麻醉期间增加脑电双频指数监测并不会带来任何益处,反而会增加成本。