Fernando Sumadhya D, Herath Sathya, Rodrigo Chaturaka, Rajapakse Senaka
Department of Parasitology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Colombo, Sri Lanka.
J Glob Infect Dis. 2011 Oct;3(4):324-8. doi: 10.4103/0974-777X.91051.
This study was designed to compare diagnosis of trichomoniasis by culture, wet smear examination, and Giemsa stain. A modified technique was used to transport and prepare the specimen to ensure parasite viability prior to Giemsa staining.
A clinic-based prospective study was carried out in association with the National STD/AIDS Control Programme over a period of 18 months. Three swabs were collected from the posterior fornix of 346 newly registered female patients for diagnosis of trichomoniasis. A wet smear was prepared using the first swab. The second swab was placed in 5 mL of 0.9% saline with three drops of 5% glucose at room temperature and centrifuged twice at a low speed prior to preparation of a Giemsa stained smear. The third swab was for culture. The three tests were performed independently. The specificity and sensitivity of the wet smear and Giemsa stain were compared to culture.
With culture, the prevalence of trichomoniasis was 6.9% (95% CI: 4.1-9.3%). The Giemsa-stained smear was found to be highly sensitive (100%, 95% CI: 86.2-100%) and specific (99.69%, 95% CI: 98.26-99.95%) compared to culture. The wet smear was less sensitive (95.83%, 95% CI: 79.76-99.26%) but equally specific (100%, 95% CI: 98.82-100%).
In developing countries, facilities for using culture are limited and wet smear examination in the field is also difficult due to the immediate need for laboratory facilities. Our study demonstrated that, in this setting, using a transport medium prior to Giemsa staining is a feasible alternative, with a high-diagnostic yield.
本研究旨在比较通过培养、湿涂片检查和吉姆萨染色诊断滴虫病的效果。采用一种改良技术来运送和制备标本,以确保在吉姆萨染色前寄生虫的活力。
与国家性传播疾病/艾滋病控制项目合作,在18个月的时间里开展了一项基于诊所的前瞻性研究。从346名新登记的女性患者的后穹窿采集三根拭子用于滴虫病诊断。用第一根拭子制备湿涂片。第二根拭子置于5毫升含三滴5%葡萄糖的0.9%盐水中,室温下低速离心两次,然后制备吉姆萨染色涂片。第三根拭子用于培养。三项检测独立进行。将湿涂片和吉姆萨染色的特异性和敏感性与培养法进行比较。
通过培养,滴虫病的患病率为6.9%(95%置信区间:4.1 - 9.3%)。与培养法相比,吉姆萨染色涂片具有高度敏感性(100%,95%置信区间:86.2 - 100%)和特异性(99.69%,95%置信区间:98.26 - 99.95%)。湿涂片敏感性较低(95.83%,95%置信区间:79.76 - 99.26%),但特异性相同(100%,95%置信区间:98.82 - 100%)。
在发展中国家,进行培养的设施有限,且由于现场立即需要实验室设施,湿涂片检查也存在困难。我们的研究表明,在这种情况下,吉姆萨染色前使用运送培养基是一种可行的替代方法,诊断率高。