Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Québec Research Centre, Hôpital Saint-François d'Assise, 10 rue de l'Espinay, D6-726, Quebec, QC G1L 3L5, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2012 Jan 16;12:14. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-12-14.
The literature recognizes a need for greater patient involvement in health technology assessment (HTA), but few studies have been reported, especially at the local level. Following the decentralisation of HTA in Quebec, Canada, the last few years have seen the creation of HTA units in many Quebec university hospital centres. These units represent a unique opportunity for increased patient involvement in HTA at the local level. Our project will engage patients in an assessment being carried out by a local HTA team to assess alternatives to isolation and restraint for hospitalized or institutionalized adults. Our objectives are to: 1) validate a reference framework for exploring the relevance and applicability of various models of patient involvement in HTA, 2) implement strategies that involve patients (including close relatives and representatives) at different stages of the HTA process, 3) evaluate intervention processes, and 4) explore the impact of these interventions on a) the applicability and acceptability of recommendations arising from the assessment, b) patient satisfaction, and c) the sustainability of this approach in HTA.
For Objective 1, we will conduct individual interviews with various stakeholders affected by the use of alternatives to isolation and restraint for hospitalized or institutionalized adults. For Objective 2, we will implement three specific strategies for patient involvement in HTA: a) direct participation in the HTA process, b) consultation of patients or their close relatives through data collection, and c) patient involvement in the dissemination of HTA results. For Objectives 3 and 4, we will evaluate the intervention processes and the impact of patient involvement strategies on the recommendations arising from the HTA and the understanding of the ethical and social implications of the HTA.
This project is likely to influence future HTA practices because it directly targets knowledge users' need for strategies that increase patient involvement in HTA. By documenting the processes and outcomes of these involvement strategies, the project will contribute to the knowledge base related to patient involvement in HTA.
文献认识到需要让更多的患者参与健康技术评估(HTA),但很少有研究报告,特别是在地方一级。在加拿大魁北克的 HTA 去中心化之后,过去几年许多魁北克大学医院中心都设立了 HTA 部门。这些单位为在地方一级增加患者参与 HTA 提供了独特的机会。我们的项目将让患者参与当地 HTA 小组进行的评估,以评估替代隔离和约束的方法,适用于住院或住院的成年人。我们的目标是:1)验证一个参考框架,用于探索各种患者参与 HTA 的模式的相关性和适用性,2)实施在 HTA 过程的不同阶段涉及患者(包括近亲代表)的策略,3)评估干预过程,4)探讨这些干预措施对以下方面的影响:a)评估产生的建议的适用性和可接受性,b)患者满意度,c)HTA 中这种方法的可持续性。
为了实现目标 1,我们将对受替代隔离和约束方法用于住院或住院的成年人的各种利益相关者进行个人访谈。为了实现目标 2,我们将实施三种具体的 HTA 患者参与策略:a)直接参与 HTA 过程,b)通过数据收集咨询患者或其近亲,c)患者参与 HTA 结果的传播。为了实现目标 3 和 4,我们将评估干预过程以及患者参与策略对 HTA 产生的建议以及对 HTA 的伦理和社会影响的理解的影响。
该项目可能会影响未来的 HTA 实践,因为它直接针对知识用户增加患者参与 HTA 的策略的需求。通过记录这些参与策略的过程和结果,该项目将为 HTA 患者参与的知识库做出贡献。