Whedon James M, Song Yunjie
The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, Lebanon, NH 03766, USA.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2012 Feb;35(2):101-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jmpt.2011.12.004. Epub 2012 Jan 16.
The purpose of this study was to measure geographic variations in the availability and use of chiropractic under Medicare.
A cross-sectional design was used to analyze a large nationally representative sample of Medicare data. Data from a 20% representative sample of all paid Medicare Part B fee-for-service claims for 2007 were merged with files containing beneficiary and provider data. The sample was restricted to adults aged 65 to 99 years. Measures of chiropractic availability and use were described and selectively mapped by state. Geographic variations were quantified. Spearman test was used to evaluate for correlation between chiropractic availability and use.
The average number of doctors of chiropractic (DC) by state was 1135; average DC per 1000 beneficiaries was 2.5 (SD, 1.1). The average number of chiropractic users by state was 34,502 (SD, 30,844); average chiropractic users per 1000 beneficiaries was 76 (SD, 41). Chiropractic availability by state varied 6-fold, and chiropractic use varied nearly 30-fold. Availability was strongly correlated with use (Spearman ρ, 0.86; P < .001). Expenditures per DC were highest in the upper Midwest and lowest in the far West; expenditures per user were highest in New England and New York, and lowest in the West.
Chiropractic availability and use by older adults under Medicare predominated in rural states in the North Central United States. Expenditures were higher in the East and Midwest and lower in the far West. Chiropractic availability and use by state were highly correlated. Future analyses should use small-area analysis and statistical modeling to identify factors predictive of chiropractic use.
本研究旨在衡量医疗保险制度下整脊疗法服务可及性及使用情况的地区差异。
采用横断面设计,对具有全国代表性的大量医疗保险数据样本进行分析。2007年所有已支付的医疗保险B部分按服务收费索赔的20%代表性样本数据,与包含受益人和提供者数据的文件合并。样本仅限于65至99岁的成年人。描述了整脊疗法服务的可及性及使用情况指标,并按州进行了选择性映射。对地区差异进行了量化。采用Spearman检验评估整脊疗法服务可及性与使用情况之间的相关性。
各州整脊疗法医生(DC)的平均数量为1135名;每1000名受益人中的DC平均数量为2.5名(标准差为1.1)。各州整脊疗法使用者的平均数量为34502名(标准差为30844);每1000名受益人中的整脊疗法使用者平均数量为76名(标准差为41)。各州整脊疗法服务的可及性差异达6倍,整脊疗法的使用差异近30倍。可及性与使用情况密切相关(Spearman ρ=0.86;P<0.001)。每位DC的支出在中西部上游地区最高,在最西部最低;每位使用者的支出在新英格兰和纽约最高,在西部最低。
医疗保险制度下美国北部中部农村各州的老年人对整脊疗法服务的可及性及使用情况占主导地位。东部和中西部的支出较高,最西部较低。各州整脊疗法服务的可及性与使用情况高度相关。未来的分析应采用小区域分析和统计建模来确定预测整脊疗法使用情况的因素。