Bordeianu Constantin-Dan, Ticu Cristina-Eugenia
Department of Ophthalmology, Emergency Hospital, Ploiesti, Romania.
Clin Ophthalmol. 2012;6:23-31. doi: 10.2147/OPTH.S13674. Epub 2011 Dec 30.
To evaluate to what extent contemporary glaucoma abstracts offer complete information and to suggest a new manner of pressure results reporting.
MATERIALS, METHODS, AND RESULTS: Most of the 36 relevant surgical glaucoma abstracts found in one issue of International Glaucoma Review contain insufficient data-supported statements. Such abstracts cannot offer a clear picture of the study essence if economic, linguistic, or political barriers prevent access to the full text. In order to enrich abstract content and to avoid typographic space waste, a formula is suggested to provide, in one single line of symbols and figures, all the necessary data for statistical interpretation at two evolution moments: the first significative control (6 months) and the final one.
The current manner of results reporting in surgical glaucoma abstracts is subject to too little standardization, allowing insufficiently data-supported statements. Abstracts, especially those printed in small-circulation language journals, should be conceived and standardized in such a manner that any abstract review reader is capable of grasping the essence of the study at first glance. The suggested manner of reporting results would bring satisfaction to all areas of the process. Publishers would save typographic space, readers would find all the necessary data for statistical analysis and comparison with other studies, and authors would be convinced that the essence of their work would penetrate in spite of any economic, linguistic, or political barriers.
评估当代青光眼摘要在多大程度上提供了完整信息,并建议一种新的眼压结果报告方式。
材料、方法与结果:在一期《国际青光眼综述》中发现的36篇相关青光眼手术摘要,大多包含的数据支持性陈述不足。如果经济、语言或政治障碍阻碍获取全文,此类摘要无法清晰呈现研究精髓。为丰富摘要内容并避免排版空间浪费,建议采用一种公式,在一行符号和数字中提供两个演变时刻(首次有意义的对照[6个月]和最后时刻)进行统计解读所需的所有必要数据。
目前青光眼手术摘要中的结果报告方式标准化程度过低,允许数据支持不足的陈述。摘要,尤其是那些发表在小发行量语言期刊上的摘要,应以这样一种方式构思和标准化,即任何摘要审阅读者都能一眼领会研究精髓。建议的结果报告方式将使该过程的所有方面都感到满意。出版商将节省排版空间,读者将找到进行统计分析以及与其他研究进行比较所需的所有必要数据,作者也会相信,尽管存在任何经济、语言或政治障碍,其工作的精髓仍能得以传达。