Vernillo Anthony, Welie Jos V M, Naidoo Sudeshni, Malamud Daniel
Department of Oral & Maxillofacial Pathology, Radiology & Medicine, New York University College of Dentistry, USA.
J Am Coll Dent. 2011 Fall;78(3):33-40.
Saliva may be a legal and ethical counterpart of other bodily fluids in diagnostic testing to blood and urine, with regard to its role in diagnostic testing. Two paradigms that have been proposed in the literature to address these challenges are reviewed in this paper. The first is centered on ownership and property rights to saliva, including financial compensation from commercially developed products using saliva. The commodification of saliva as property is also discussed. The second paradigm is related to privacy and the potential for genetic discrimination, given the unwarranted disclosure of confidential information. The management of saliva specimens from dental patients and research participants will also require the implementation of innovative approaches to obtain informed consent.
就唾液在诊断测试中的作用而言,在诊断测试中,唾液可能是与血液和尿液等其他体液具有同等合法性和伦理地位的样本。本文回顾了文献中提出的应对这些挑战的两种模式。第一种模式围绕唾液的所有权和财产权,包括从使用唾液的商业开发产品中获得经济补偿。还讨论了将唾液作为财产进行商品化的问题。第二种模式涉及隐私以及基因歧视的可能性,因为存在机密信息被不当披露的情况。对牙科患者和研究参与者的唾液样本进行管理也需要采用创新方法来获得知情同意。