International Centre for Allied Health Evidence, School of Health Sciences, University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia.
Ultrasound Med Biol. 2012 Mar;38(3):368-76. doi: 10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2011.12.012. Epub 2012 Jan 21.
This prospective, blinded study investigates the test retest reliability of measures of muscle thickness made by one sonographer across two cohort groups (n = 29) of people hospitalised with acute stroke. Reliability was assessed in cohort one (n = 14) for measurements made bilaterally at the anterior and posterior upper arms, the anterior and posterior thighs (total of eight measurements) and in cohort two (n = 15), for measurements made bilaterally at the lateral forearms, the anterior abdominal wall and the anterior and lower legs (total of eight measurements). Reliability estimates varied between measurement sites; intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) ranged from -0.26 (lateral forearm, paretic side) to 0.95 (anterior thigh, nonparetic side), percent mean differences ranged from 0.42% (posterior upper arm, nonparetic side) to 14.68% (anterior lower limb, nonparetic side) and method error ranged from 1.08 (abdomen, nonparetic side) to 9.69 mm (posterior lower limb, nonparetic side). Only four measurement sites (anterior upper arm, posterior upper arm, abdomen and anterior thigh) were within the acceptable ranges (ICC 0.60 to 1.00, mean percent difference range 0%-5% and method error range 0-5 mm) and considered reliable to use for measures of muscle thickness in people hospitalised with acute stroke.
这项前瞻性、盲法研究调查了一名超声科医生在两个急性脑卒中住院患者队列组(n=29)中测量肌肉厚度的测试-重测信度。在队列 1(n=14)中,对双侧上臂前侧和后侧、双侧大腿前侧和后侧(共 8 个测量部位)进行了测量,在队列 2(n=15)中,对双侧前臂外侧、前腹壁和双侧小腿前侧和后侧(共 8 个测量部位)进行了测量,评估了可靠性。测量部位的可靠性评估结果不同;组内相关系数(ICC)范围为 -0.26(患侧前臂外侧)至 0.95(非患侧大腿前侧),平均差异百分比范围为 0.42%(非患侧上臂后侧)至 14.68%(非患侧小腿前侧),方法误差范围为 1.08(非患侧腹部)至 9.69mm(非患侧小腿后侧)。只有四个测量部位(患侧上臂前侧、患侧上臂后侧、腹部和非患侧大腿前侧)在可接受范围内(ICC 0.60 至 1.00,平均差异百分比范围 0%-5%,方法误差范围 0-5mm),可用于测量急性脑卒中住院患者的肌肉厚度。