Department of Health Services Research and Administration, College of Public Health, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE 68198, USA.
J Public Health Manag Pract. 2012 Mar-Apr;18(2):148-55. doi: 10.1097/PHH.0b013e318239918f.
The purpose of this study is to examine the effectiveness and challenges of regional public health partnerships by exploring the experiences of 2 multicounty LHDs in Nebraska.
The selection of the 2 local health department (LHD) sites was on the basis of the history of prior collaborative partnership in the LHD jurisdiction. Both regional LHD jurisdictions cover a service area of 9 counties.
A mixed method research design was used for this study. We first conducted an online survey to create an inventory of partnerships for each LHD site. Then, we collected quantitative data to measure the effectiveness of partnerships through a survey of community partners in both LHD sites. We also collected qualitative information through telephone interviews with community partners and LHD staff to examine the challenges for building an effective regional partnership.
Regional public health partnerships are most effective in efficiency, but less effective in the areas of management and resource sufficiency. More effort is still needed to maximize the collaborative potential for the majority of partnerships in both regions. In particular, geographic distance and work demand were identified as the 2 major challenges by community partners. The community health planning partnership in the LHD site with prior history of collaboration was more effective than its counterpart without such history.
Policy makers should consider developing policies to assist multicounty LHDs with improving their management of regional partnerships and with providing sufficient resources to support their regional partnerships. If possible, the formation of regional community health planning partnership should follow the geographic boundaries where prior collaboration already existed.
本研究旨在通过探索内布拉斯加州两个多县 LHD 的经验,考察区域公共卫生伙伴关系的有效性和挑战。
选择这两个地方卫生部门(LHD)地点是基于 LHD 管辖范围内先前合作伙伴关系的历史。两个区域 LHD 辖区均覆盖 9 个县的服务区。
本研究采用混合方法研究设计。我们首先对每个 LHD 地点进行了在线调查,以创建伙伴关系清单。然后,我们通过对两个 LHD 地点的社区合作伙伴进行调查,收集定量数据来衡量伙伴关系的有效性。我们还通过电话访谈社区合作伙伴和 LHD 工作人员收集定性信息,以研究建立有效区域伙伴关系的挑战。
区域公共卫生伙伴关系在效率方面最为有效,但在管理和资源充足性方面效果较差。仍需要付出更多努力,以最大限度地发挥两个地区大多数伙伴关系的协同潜力。特别是,地理距离和工作需求被社区合作伙伴确定为两个主要挑战。在有合作历史的 LHD 地点的社区卫生规划伙伴关系比没有合作历史的伙伴关系更有效。
政策制定者应考虑制定政策,以协助多县 LHD 改善其对区域伙伴关系的管理,并为其区域伙伴关系提供充足的资源。如果可能,应按照先前已经存在合作的地理边界形成区域社区卫生规划伙伴关系。