Brown Jennifer J, Weisler Richard H
Medscape, LLC, New York, New York, USA.
Prim Care Companion CNS Disord. 2011;13(5). doi: 10.4088/PCC.11m01171.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a signature injury of war among returning soldiers and US National Guard and Reserve members, with symptoms even more likely on rescreening. Studies that examine health care provider screening and referral practices outside the military for these patients are needed. The objective of this study was to assess health care provider PTSD practices and barriers to care.
A 25-item, anonymous Internet questionnaire was developed as an educational needs assessment survey based on the US Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense PTSD guideline and the companion, primary care-directed PTSD Screening and Referral for Health Care Providers of the National Center for PTSD. The assessment design included patient vignettes followed by multiple-choice questions and was distributed on the Internet to health care providers free of charge and without compensation. Of 1,338 participant health care providers, mainly from primary care and mental health specialties, 507 responded to the questions. Participant privacy was maintained for the self-assessment survey, and all responses were deidentified and analyzed in aggregate. Overall participant responses and subgroups of primary care and mental health questionnaire responses were scored against guidelines. Participant data responses to survey questions were collected from August 20, 2010, to October 3, 2010.
Gaps in screening skills compared with guidelines were shown, as PTSD diagnosis questions were correctly answered by 51% of primary care and 56% of mental health providers. Real-world screening and referral differed from guidelines, as only 24% of primary care and 48% of mental health providers have a system in place to routinely screen for mental health in their patients who are returning service members. Only 25% of primary care providers had access to referral to mental health services, showing large gaps in care. Stigma associated with mental disorders was the practice barrier most frequently cited by health care providers.
The study identified gaps in PTSD screening and linkage to care among health care providers. Further training efforts and resources are needed to screen patients and to reduce barriers to care.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)是退伍军人以及美国国民警卫队和预备役军人中战争所致的典型伤病,再次筛查时症状出现的可能性更高。需要开展研究,考察针对这些患者在军队以外的医疗服务提供者的筛查及转诊做法。本研究的目的是评估医疗服务提供者对PTSD的诊疗做法及护理障碍。
基于美国退伍军人事务部和国防部的PTSD指南以及美国国家PTSD中心面向医疗服务提供者的《PTSD筛查与转诊初级护理指南》,编制了一份包含25个条目的匿名网络调查问卷,作为教育需求评估调查。评估设计包括患者案例,随后是多项选择题,通过互联网免费发放给医疗服务提供者,无任何报酬。在1338名参与调查的医疗服务提供者中,主要来自初级护理和精神卫生专业,507人回答了问题。自我评估调查中维护了参与者的隐私,所有回答均进行了去识别化处理并汇总分析。总体参与者的回答以及初级护理和精神卫生问卷回答的子组均根据指南进行评分。参与者对调查问题的数据回答收集于2010年8月20日至2010年10月3日。
与指南相比,筛查技能存在差距,初级护理提供者中51%、精神卫生提供者中56%正确回答了PTSD诊断问题。实际的筛查和转诊与指南不同,只有24%的初级护理提供者和48%的精神卫生提供者有一套系统,对退伍军人患者进行常规心理健康筛查。只有25%的初级护理提供者能够转诊至精神卫生服务机构,显示出护理方面存在很大差距。与精神障碍相关的污名是医疗服务提供者最常提到的执业障碍。
该研究发现了医疗服务提供者在PTSD筛查及与护理衔接方面的差距。需要进一步开展培训工作并提供资源,以筛查患者并减少护理障碍。