Dumay A C, Zijdenbos A P, Pinto I M, Gerbrands J J, Roos C, Serruys P W, Reiber J H
Thoraxcenter, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Int J Card Imaging. 1990;5(2-3):213-24. doi: 10.1007/BF01833990.
In theory, radiographic myocardial perfusion imaging allows a quantitative assessment of the functional significance of a coronary stenosis. However, in the conventional two-dimensional projection images there does not exist a one-two-one relationship between a selected myocardial region of interest (ROI) and one particular coronary segment perfusing that area due to over-projection of myocardial regions in front of and behind the selected ROI perfused by other arterial segments, which may result in measurements which are difficult to interpret or even unreliable. To overcome these problems, we have developed two algorithms to determine the spatial distribution of perfusion levels in slices of the heart, selected approximately perpendicular to the left ventricular long axis, from two orthogonal angiographic views: the Segmental Reconstruction Technique (SRT) and the Network Programming Reconstruction Technique (NPRT). Both techniques require a priori geometric information about the myocardium, which can be obtained from the epicardial coronary tree (epicardial boundaries) and the left ventricular lumen (endocardial boundaries). Using the SRT approach, pie-shaped segments are defined for each slice within the myocardial geometric constraints such that superimposition of these segments when projected in orthogonal biplane views is minimal. The reconstruction process uses a model with identical myocardial geometry and definition of segments. Each segment of the model is assigned a relative perfusion level with unit one if no other a priori information is available. In this case, the model contains geometric information only. In case a priori information about expected segmental perfusion levels is available, a level between zero and one is assigned to each segment. The a priori information on the myocardial perfusion levels can be extracted from either anatomic information about the location and severity of existing coronary arterial obstructions, or from a slice adjacent to the one under reconstruction. Using the NPRT approach perfusion levels are computed for each volume picture element of a slice within the reconstructed myocardial geometry, thus resulting in a much higher spatial resolution than the SRT approach. A priori information of perfusion levels must be included in this approach, again based upon anatomical information, or upon the slice adjacent to the one under reconstruction. The very first slice of a myocardial study will be reconstructed by the SRT approach. Extensive computer simulations for the SRT have proved that the mean difference between the actual and reconstructed segmental perfusion levels, on a scale from 0 to 1, is smaller than 0.45 (SEE = 0.0033, REE = 1.80) for various coronary artery disease states without the use of a priori information on expected perfusion levels. This error becomes smaller than 0.36 (SEE = 0.0026, REE = 1.42), if a priori information in the reconstruction technique is included. Similar computer simulations for the NPRT have proved that these mean differences in geometric segments equal to those defined for the SRT, are smaller than 2.94 (SEE = 0.0308, REE = 0.77) on a scale from 0 to 16, without the use of a priori information on expected perfusion levels, and smaller than 1.72 (SEE = 0.0304, REE = 1.10) on the same scale when a priori information is included. Therefore, it may be concluded that slice-wise three-dimensional reconstruction of perfusion levels is feasible from biplane computer-simulated data, and that a similarity exists for mean perfusion levels in corresponding regions in the simulated and reconstructed slices, for various states of single coronary artery disease.
理论上,放射状心肌灌注成像能够对冠状动脉狭窄的功能意义进行定量评估。然而,在传统的二维投影图像中,由于在选定的感兴趣心肌区域(ROI)前方和后方的心肌区域被其他动脉段灌注而产生的重叠投影,选定的心肌ROI与灌注该区域的一个特定冠状动脉节段之间不存在一一对应的关系,这可能导致测量结果难以解释甚至不可靠。为了克服这些问题,我们开发了两种算法,用于从两个正交血管造影视图确定心脏切片中灌注水平的空间分布,这些切片大致垂直于左心室长轴:节段重建技术(SRT)和网络编程重建技术(NPRT)。这两种技术都需要有关心肌的先验几何信息,这些信息可以从心外膜冠状动脉树(心外膜边界)和左心室内腔(心内膜边界)获得。使用SRT方法,在心肌几何约束范围内为每个切片定义扇形节段,使得这些节段在正交双平面视图中投影时的重叠最小。重建过程使用具有相同心肌几何形状和节段定义的模型。如果没有其他先验信息,模型的每个节段都被赋予一个相对灌注水平,单位为1。在这种情况下,模型仅包含几何信息。如果有关于预期节段灌注水平的先验信息,则为每个节段分配一个介于0和1之间的水平。关于心肌灌注水平的先验信息可以从有关现有冠状动脉阻塞的位置和严重程度的解剖信息中提取,或者从与正在重建的切片相邻的切片中提取。使用NPRT方法,在重建的心肌几何形状内为切片的每个体素计算灌注水平,因此与SRT方法相比具有更高的空间分辨率。同样基于解剖信息或正在重建的切片相邻的切片,此方法必须包含灌注水平的先验信息。心肌研究的第一个切片将通过SRT方法进行重建。对SRT进行的广泛计算机模拟证明,在不使用预期灌注水平的先验信息的情况下,对于各种冠状动脉疾病状态,实际节段灌注水平与重建节段灌注水平之间在0到1的范围内的平均差异小于0.45(标准误差 = 0.0033,相对误差 = 1.80)。如果在重建技术中包含先验信息,该误差将小于0.36(标准误差 = 0.0026,相对误差 = 1.42)。对NPRT进行的类似计算机模拟证明,在不使用预期灌注水平的先验信息的情况下,这些与SRT定义的几何节段相等的节段的平均差异在0到16的范围内小于2.94(标准误差 = 0.0308,相对误差 = 0.77),当包含先验信息时,在相同范围内小于1.72(标准误差 = 0.0304,相对误差 = 1.10)。因此,可以得出结论,从双平面计算机模拟数据进行切片式三维灌注水平重建是可行的,并且对于各种单冠状动脉疾病状态,模拟切片和重建切片中相应区域的平均灌注水平存在相似性。