Functional Digestive Rehabilitation Unit, Institut Guttmann, Neurorehabilitation Hospital, University Institute affiliated with the Autonomous University of Barcelona, Badalona, Spain.
Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2012 May;24(5):414-9, e206. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2982.2011.01869.x. Epub 2012 Feb 6.
The chin-down posture is generally recommended in patients with neurogenic dysphagia to prevent tracheal aspiration; however, its effectiveness has not been demonstrated.
To videofluoroscopically (VDF) assess the effectiveness of chin-down posture to prevent aspiration in patients with neurogenic dysphagia secondary to acquired brain injury.
Randomized, alternating, cross-over study (with and without the chin-down posture) in 47 patients with a VDF diagnosis of aspiration [31 stroke, 16 traumatic brain injury (TBI)] and 25 controls without aspiration (14 stroke, 11 TBI).
During the chin-down posture, 55% of patients avoided aspiration (40% preswallow aspiration and 60% aspiration during swallow). The percentage was similar in both etiologies (58% stroke and 50% TBI). Fifty-one percent of patients had silent aspiration; of these, 48% persisted with aspiration while in the chin-down posture. A statistically significant relationship was found between the existence of pharyngeal residue, cricopharyngeal dysfunction, pharyngeal delay time and bolus volume with the persistence of aspiration. The chin-down posture did not change swallow biomechanics in patients without aspiration.
CONCLUSIONS & INFERENCES: Only half the patients with acquired brain injury avoided aspiration during cervical flexion; 48% of silent aspirators continued to aspire during the maneuver. Several videofluoroscopic parameters were related to inefficiency of the maneuver. Therefore, the indication for chin-down posture should be evaluated by videofluoroscopic examination.
颏下倾姿势通常被推荐用于治疗神经源性吞咽困难以防止气管吸入,但尚未证明其有效性。
使用视频透视吞咽功能检查(VFSS)评估颏下倾姿势在因后天性脑损伤导致的神经源性吞咽困难患者中预防吸入的效果。
对 47 例有吸入 VFSS 诊断的患者(31 例中风,16 例创伤性脑损伤(TBI))和 25 例无吸入的对照组(14 例中风,11 例 TBI)进行随机、交替、交叉研究(有和无颏下倾姿势)。
在颏下倾姿势期间,55%的患者避免了吸入(40%在吞咽前吸入,60%在吞咽时吸入)。两种病因的比例相似(中风 58%,TBI 50%)。51%的患者有隐性吸入;其中 48%在颏下倾姿势时仍存在吸入。发现咽后残留物、环咽肌功能障碍、咽延迟时间和食团体积与吸入的持续存在之间存在统计学显著关系。颏下倾姿势并未改变无吸入的患者的吞咽生物力学。
后天性脑损伤患者中只有一半在颈椎屈曲时避免了吸入;48%的隐性吸入者在该操作期间仍继续吸入。几个视频透视参数与该操作的效率低下有关。因此,颏下倾姿势的适应证应通过视频透视检查来评估。