Department of Neurology, Johann Wolfgang Goethe University, Frankfurt/Main, Germany.
J Neuropsychol. 2012 Sep;6(2):257-69. doi: 10.1111/j.1748-6653.2012.02026.x. Epub 2012 Feb 13.
It has been argued that executive tests should capture central aspects of executive functions in everyday life such as initiating and monitoring parallel actions in low-structured environments (so-called multitasking; see Burgess, 2000). We present a cooking task in order to assess executive function impairments in brain-damaged patients, which focuses on a central feature of multitasking, the interleaving of tasks (Burgess, 2000). Behavioural performance of 21 brain-damaged patients (stroke, traumatic brain injury) and of a group of matched controls was analysed on the basis of a standardized protocol. In comparison to controls, the patients explored less, were less successful in monitoring their actions and corrected errors less efficiently. Interleaving of actions was observed less frequently in patients, with respect to both cooking itself as well as to subordinate goals (e.g., cleaning up). Interleaving proved efficient, as it was associated with less time to complete the task. Patients' scores in the cooking task correlated with performance in both the Behavioural Assessment of the Dysexecutive Syndrome (BADS) Zoo Map Test and the BADS Six Elements Test, but not with tests of attention, verbal memory, or figural fluency, thus demonstrating convergent and discriminant validity. In summary, our task demonstrates that cooking can provide a valid testing ground for assessing a central aspect of everyday multitasking demands, namely, the interleaving of actions.
有人认为,执行测试应该捕捉日常生活中执行功能的核心方面,例如在低结构环境中启动和监控并行动作(即所谓的多任务处理;参见 Burgess,2000)。我们提出了一个烹饪任务,以评估脑损伤患者的执行功能障碍,该任务侧重于多任务处理的一个核心特征,即任务的交错(Burgess,2000)。根据标准化协议,分析了 21 名脑损伤患者(中风、创伤性脑损伤)和一组匹配对照组的行为表现。与对照组相比,患者的探索较少,在监控自己的动作方面成功率较低,并且纠正错误的效率较低。与烹饪本身以及从属目标(例如,清理)相比,患者的动作交错较少。交错被证明是有效的,因为它与完成任务的时间较短有关。患者在烹饪任务中的得分与行为执行功能障碍评估量表(BADS)动物园地图测试和 BADS 六要素测试中的表现相关,但与注意力、言语记忆或图形流畅性测试无关,因此表现出收敛和判别效度。总之,我们的任务表明,烹饪可以为评估日常多任务处理需求的一个核心方面,即动作的交错,提供一个有效的测试基础。