Sadideen H, Parikh A, Dobbs T, Pay A, Critchley P S
Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2012 Apr;94(3):152-4. doi: 10.1308/003588412X13171221501861. Epub 2012 Feb 16.
It is well documented that music plays a role in reducing anxiety levels. Its role in reducing intra-operative anxiety levels in surgical patients while awake is less well known. We report the effects of music on intra-operative patient anxiety in both the elective and trauma plastic surgical setting.
Two groups of patients undergoing local anaesthetic surgical procedures were identified: those where music was played in the operating theatre (Group 1) and those where it was not (Group 2). Ninety-six patients were included. Subjectively anxiety was evaluated by the patient with a visual analogue scale (VAS) and objectively by the respiratory rate (RR), both pre and post-operatively. The unpaired t-test was used to evaluate the statistical significance of differences between the groups.
The mean pre-operative VAS score was similar in both groups (5.7 in Group 1 and 5.8 in Group 2). The mean pre-operative RR was 15 breaths per minute in both groups. Post-operatively, the VAS score and RR were both lower in Group 1 (VAS: 3.5 vs 4.9; p<0.01 and RR: 11 vs 13 breaths per minute; p<0.05).
In the era of the patient centred approach to clinical care, it is crucial to minimise patient anxiety. Music appears to reduce intra-operative anxiety in awake patients in both the elective and trauma plastic surgical setting. Easy listening music and chart classics appear to be suitable genres according to patients. We believe there is a role for a large, multicentre, randomised control study to examine the benefits of music in all local anaesthetic procedures across different specialties.
有充分的文献记载表明音乐在降低焦虑水平方面发挥着作用。而其在降低清醒手术患者术中焦虑水平方面的作用则鲜为人知。我们报告了音乐在择期和创伤整形手术环境中对术中患者焦虑的影响。
确定了两组接受局部麻醉手术的患者:一组是在手术室播放音乐的患者(第1组),另一组是未播放音乐的患者(第2组)。共纳入96例患者。术前和术后分别通过视觉模拟量表(VAS)由患者主观评估焦虑程度,并通过呼吸频率(RR)进行客观评估。采用非配对t检验评估两组之间差异的统计学显著性。
两组术前VAS平均评分相似(第1组为5.7,第2组为5.8)。两组术前RR平均均为每分钟15次呼吸。术后,第1组的VAS评分和RR均较低(VAS:3.5对4.9;p<0.01;RR:每分钟11次对13次呼吸;p<0.05)。
在以患者为中心的临床护理时代,将患者焦虑降至最低至关重要。音乐似乎能降低择期和创伤整形手术环境中清醒患者的术中焦虑。根据患者的情况,轻音乐和经典曲目似乎是合适的音乐类型。我们认为有必要开展一项大型、多中心、随机对照研究,以探讨音乐在不同专科的所有局部麻醉手术中的益处。