University of Malta, Msida, Malta,
Psychiatr Danub. 2021 Dec;33(Suppl 11):100-115.
Intra-operative anxiety is a commonly experienced feeling amongst patients undergoing surgery. Moreover, conscious patients are exposed to the multiple environmental factors triggering this emotion. Apprehension and fear are common emotions interlinked with associated intra-operative anxiety. Several concerning complications are associated with this emotion during surgery, many of which include severe cardiac related events, such as heart failure and acute myocardial infarction, extreme postoperative pain, increased requirement of analgesic, sedation and anaesthetic demand, extended hospital stay, and reduced patient satisfaction. In this review, the effect of intra-operative music therapy to alleviate anxiety in adults undergoing surgery will be studied in order to establish whether intra-operative music alleviates anxiety in adults undergoing local anaesthetic surgical interventions.
The Population studied was adults aged 18-80 years old undergoing local anaesthetic interventions. The Intervention observed was the exposure of intra-operative music therapy. The Comparison was against patients undergoing surgery without being subject to music therapy. The desired Outcome was the alleviation of intra-operative anxiety. The intention was to develop a systematic review of the available data. In orderto develop the literature search, Key elements of the question were identified and utilized to generate alternative terms. Subsequently, Boolean Operators were used to combine these terms. Search results were narrowed down by means of limiters and selected databases; EBSCO, PubMed and ScienceDirect were used to execute the search. The PRISMA 2009 framework was used as a guideline in excluding irrelevant studies. Assessment of study eligibility was done byapplying inclusion/exclusion criteria. Appraisal of literature was done by using The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) tool as a framework.
A total of five studies were identified. These included randomised control trials. Two of these studies demonstrated statistical significance whilst the remaining three failed to do so. The overall result of these studies was inconclusive and inconsistent in attempting to determine whether intra-operative music therapy alleviates anxiety in patients undergoing local anaesthetic interventions.
The presentation of a definite conclusion is not possible. However, evidence is promising and pointing towards the likelihood of beneficial outcomes resulting from the intervention of interest. However, further research is required.
It is recommended that the patients be offered the choice of selecting their preferred music if they give consent to undergo surgery while being exposed to music therapy. Various cost-effective audio devices could be installed in operating theatres. The general public and healthcare professionals should be educated about the benefits of intra-operative music therapy. Future studies should use larger sample sizes, and attrition rate should be reduced through better communication with patients and thorough taking into account the demographic characteristics of the patients.
术中焦虑是手术患者常见的感受。此外,意识清醒的患者会接触到引发这种情绪的多种环境因素。焦虑和恐惧是与相关术中焦虑相关的常见情绪。在手术过程中,这种情绪会引起多种令人担忧的并发症,其中许多包括严重的心脏相关事件,如心力衰竭和急性心肌梗死、极度术后疼痛、增加对镇痛药、镇静剂和麻醉剂的需求、延长住院时间和降低患者满意度。在这项综述中,将研究术中音乐疗法对减轻接受手术的成年人焦虑的影响,以确定术中音乐是否能减轻接受局部麻醉手术干预的成年人的焦虑。
研究对象为年龄在 18 至 80 岁之间接受局部麻醉干预的成年人。观察的干预措施是暴露于术中音乐疗法。比较对象是接受手术但不接受音乐疗法的患者。期望的结果是减轻术中焦虑。目的是对现有数据进行系统综述。为了进行文献检索,确定了问题的关键要素并加以利用,以生成替代术语。然后,使用布尔运算符组合这些术语。通过限制器和选定的数据库缩小搜索结果范围;使用 EBSCO、PubMed 和 ScienceDirect 执行搜索。PRISMA 2009 框架被用作排除不相关研究的指南。通过应用纳入/排除标准来评估研究的资格。使用批判性评估技能计划 (CASP) 工具作为框架来评估文献。
共确定了五项研究。其中包括随机对照试验。其中两项研究显示具有统计学意义,而其余三项研究则没有。这些研究的总体结果不一致,无法确定术中音乐疗法是否能减轻接受局部麻醉干预的患者的焦虑。
不可能提出明确的结论。然而,证据很有希望,并指向干预可能产生有益结果的可能性。然而,还需要进一步的研究。
建议在患者同意接受音乐疗法的情况下,在手术过程中为患者提供选择他们喜欢的音乐的选择。可以在手术室中安装各种具有成本效益的音频设备。应向公众和医疗保健专业人员宣传术中音乐疗法的益处。未来的研究应使用更大的样本量,并通过与患者更好地沟通以及全面考虑患者的人口统计学特征来降低失访率。