Department of Preventive Medicine, University of Ulsan College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Telemed J E Health. 2012 Oct;18(8):604-12. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2011.0261. Epub 2012 Feb 21.
We examined physicians' perceived needs, benefits, and concerns regarding health information exchange (HIE) technology prior to experiencing it and their actual usage of exchanged information in care processes during an HIE pilot program in South Korea.
We conducted a survey through a structured questionnaire to collect data on physician perceptions about an HIE prior to implementation. We analyzed responses using descriptive statistics and one-way analyses of variance. We also conducted a post-implementation survey through a computerized tool designed to collect data on physician assessment of HIE item usefulness. We defined two indices to measure the volume of information flow and usefulness for individual HIE items and analyzed the indices with Fisher's exact test.
Physicians' overall perceptions about the need for an HIE and benefits of the technology were positive despite their concerns about information safety and security, system costs, and disputes between care providers in cases of malpractice. We found that physician practice settings significantly influenced the details of their perceptions. In the both pre- and post-implementation studies, the most needed and valued information were pathology and lab results, diagnostic imaging, medication, and working diagnosis. Physicians most agreed with the benefit potentials in the quality domain, least agreed with those in time and cost savings of healthcare delivery, and least worried about the decrease in revenues resulting from the technology.
The overall physician acceptance of the HIE technology in South Korea is promising, but the adoption and diffusion strategy needs to be tailored to the type of physician practice. Concerted efforts may be needed to realize the much-anticipated potential of healthcare cost savings.
在韩国的一项健康信息交换(HIE)试点项目中,我们在体验 HIE 技术之前,调查了医生对其的感知需求、益处和顾虑,并在 HIE 过程中研究了他们实际在医疗过程中使用所交换信息的情况。
我们通过结构化问卷进行了一项调查,以收集医生在实施 HIE 之前对 HIE 的感知数据。我们使用描述性统计和单向方差分析来分析响应。我们还通过计算机工具进行了实施后的调查,该工具旨在收集医生对 HIE 项目有用性的评估数据。我们定义了两个指标来衡量单个 HIE 项目的信息流和有用性的量,并使用 Fisher 精确检验分析了这些指标。
尽管医生对信息安全和保密性、系统成本以及医疗事故中医疗服务提供者之间的纠纷表示担忧,但他们对 HIE 的总体需求和技术益处的看法仍然是积极的。我们发现,医生的实践环境显著影响了他们看法的细节。在实施前和实施后的研究中,最需要和最有价值的信息是病理学和实验室结果、诊断成像、药物和工作诊断。医生最认同质量领域的潜在效益,最不认同医疗保健交付的时间和成本节约方面的潜在效益,最不担心该技术会导致收入减少。
韩国医生对 HIE 技术的总体接受度是有希望的,但需要根据医生实践的类型调整采用和扩散策略。可能需要共同努力,以实现预期的医疗成本节约潜力。