Center for Functional Anatomy and Evolution, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 21205, USA.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2012 Apr;147(4):661-70. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.22036. Epub 2012 Feb 27.
Qualitative methods of describing sexual dimorphism in discrete cranial traits have been criticized for their subjectivity and statistical limitations. However, researchers have yet to be able to accurately capture the morphology of these individual traits using traditional metric techniques. This article presents a method to quantify morphological variation in the skeletal browridge and chin using 3D surface laser scans. Browridge and chin regions are isolated from the skull using objectively defined landmarks and planes. Region areas and volumes are used to quantify absolute and relative size, while semilandmarks along transects are used for more detailed morphometric analyses. An intraobserver error study indicates high repeatability of the method. Application of the method is demonstrated on a sample of US males and females of black and white ancestries. Results suggest significant effects of both sex and ancestry on brow and chin morphologies and are consistent with traditional qualitative descriptions. Our results indicate that the method can accurately and reliably quantify browridge and chin morphologies, providing a tool to objectively describe and statistically analyze these traditionally qualitative discrete cranial traits.
定性方法描述离散颅特征的性别二态性一直受到其主观性和统计限制的批评。然而,研究人员还未能使用传统的度量技术准确地捕捉这些个体特征的形态。本文提出了一种使用 3D 表面激光扫描量化骨骼眉弓和下巴形态变异的方法。使用客观定义的地标和平面从颅骨中分离出眉弓和下巴区域。区域面积和体积用于量化绝对和相对大小,而沿横断面的半标志用于更详细的形态计量分析。一项观察者内误差研究表明该方法具有高度的可重复性。该方法的应用在一个具有黑白两种祖先的美国男性和女性样本中得到了验证。结果表明,性别和祖先对眉弓和下巴形态有显著影响,与传统的定性描述一致。我们的结果表明,该方法可以准确可靠地量化眉弓和下巴形态,为客观描述和统计分析这些传统的定性离散颅特征提供了一种工具。