Sharquie Khalifa E, Al-Rawi Jamal R, Noaimi Adil A, Al-Hassany Haitham M
Scientific Council of Dermatology and Venereology, Baghdad, Iraq.
J Drugs Dermatol. 2012 Mar;11(3):357-64.
Many therapeutic modalities for scabies were available, topical sulfur ointment is a cost-effective and safe therapeutic agent. It is often applied for the whole body for three successive days.
To evaluate their therapeutic regimen of 8% and 10% topical precipitated sulfur in petrolatum ointment for single day, three successive nights or three successive days in management of scabies.
This single-blinded, comparative study was conducted in the Department of Dermatology-Baghdad Teaching Hospital from April 2008 through October 2009. A total of 97 patients with scabies were enrolled in this study. The diagnosis was established on clinical basis. The patients treated with 8% and 10% topical sulfur in petrolatum ointment were divided randomly into three groups: Group A: 33 patients treated for single day (24 hours); Group B: 32 patients treated for three successive nights (from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. to 6 a.m. to 8 a.m. and bathing every day); and Group C: 32 patients treated for three successive days (bathing every 24 hours). The patients were seen regularly every two weeks for the duration of four weeks.
Study included 58 (59.8%) males and 39 (40.2%) females, with a male to female ratio 1.4:1. The age range of males at presentation from 3 to 64 (26.74±15.98) years, while the females age ranged at presentation from 3 to 60 (24.05±14.53) years of age. At the end of the study, the response to treatment was: Group A, response in 14 (42.4%) patients and no response in 19 (57.6%); Group B, response in 29 (90.6%) patients and no response in 3 (9.4%); and Group C, response in 31 (96.9%) patients and no response in 1 (3.1%). There is significant statistical difference among the response of 3 groups with (P=0.00000011), but no statistically significant difference between the response of Group C and Group B, (P=0.6055). Mild burning sensation and irritating (sulfur) dermatitis were the only side effects of 8% and 10% sulfur. Pruritic rash occurred in Group C mainly, in 11 (34.4%) patients, 8 (25%) in Group B and 4 (12.1%) in Group A, with no significance (P=0.1058). Recurrence or relapse occurred in Group A mainly, with 4 (12.1%) patients, and in Group B, 1 patient, (3.1%), with no recurrence in group C, with significance (P=0.0060).
Three successive days and three successive nights of 8% and 10% sulfur ointment were effective regimens with no statistical difference in favor of three successive days, while single-day application was much less effective but with fewer side effects.
治疗疥疮有多种方法,外用硫磺软膏是一种经济有效且安全的治疗药物。通常需连续三天全身涂抹。
评估8%和10%的沉淀硫磺凡士林软膏单日、连续三晚或连续三天外用治疗疥疮的疗效。
本单盲对照研究于2008年4月至2009年10月在巴格达教学医院皮肤科进行。共纳入97例疥疮患者,诊断基于临床症状。将外用8%和10%硫磺凡士林软膏的患者随机分为三组:A组:33例患者接受单日(24小时)治疗;B组:32例患者接受连续三晚(下午6点至晚上8点、凌晨6点至早上8点,每天沐浴)治疗;C组:32例患者接受连续三天(每24小时沐浴)治疗。在四周的时间里,每两周定期对患者进行观察。
研究纳入58例(59.8%)男性和39例(40.2%)女性,男女比例为1.4:1。男性就诊时年龄范围为3至64岁(26.74±15.98),女性就诊时年龄范围为3至60岁(24.05±14.53)。研究结束时,治疗反应如下:A组,14例(42.4%)患者有反应,19例(57.6%)无反应;B组,29例(90.6%)患者有反应,3例(9.4%)无反应;C组,31例(96.9%)患者有反应,1例(3.1%)无反应。三组反应之间存在显著统计学差异(P = 0.00000011),但C组和B组反应之间无统计学显著差异(P = 0.6055)。8%和10%硫磺的唯一副作用是轻微烧灼感和刺激性(硫磺)皮炎。瘙痒性皮疹主要发生在C组,11例(34.4%)患者出现,B组8例(25%),A组4例(12.1%),无显著性差异(P = 0.1058)。复发主要发生在A组,4例(12.1%)患者复发,B组1例(3.1%)患者复发,C组无复发,有显著性差异(P = 0.0060)。
8%和10%硫磺软膏连续三天和连续三晚外用是有效的治疗方案,连续三天使用无统计学优势,而单日应用效果差得多,但副作用较少。