Hughes Mark, Skilbeck Christopher, Saeed Shakeel, Bradford Robert
Skull Base. 2011 Sep;21(5):295-302. doi: 10.1055/s-0031-1284219.
We conducted a retrospective observational study to assess the consequences of conservative management of vestibular schwannoma (VS). Data were collected from tertiary neuro-otological referral units in United Kingdom. The study included 59 patients who were managed conservatively with radiological diagnosis of VS. The main outcome measures were growth rate and rate of failure of conservative management. Multivariate analysis sought correlation between tumor growth and (i) demographic features, (ii) tumor characteristics. The mean tumor growth was 0.66 mm/y. 11 patients (19%) required intervention. Mean time to intervention was 37 months with two notable late "failures" occurring at 75 and 84 months. Tumors extending into the cerebellopontine angle (CPA) grew significantly faster than intracanalicular tumors (p = 0.0045). No association was found between growth rate and age, sex, tumor laterality, facial nerve function, and grade of hearing loss. Conservative management is acceptable for a subset of patients. Tumors extending into the CPA at diagnosis grow significantly faster than intracanalicular tumors. No growth within 5 years of surveillance does not guarantee a continued indolent growth pattern; surveillance must therefore continue.
我们开展了一项回顾性观察性研究,以评估前庭神经鞘瘤(VS)保守治疗的后果。数据收集自英国的三级神经耳科转诊单位。该研究纳入了59例经放射学诊断为VS且接受保守治疗的患者。主要结局指标为生长速率和保守治疗失败率。多变量分析探寻肿瘤生长与(i)人口统计学特征、(ii)肿瘤特征之间的相关性。肿瘤平均生长速率为0.66 mm/年。11例患者(19%)需要干预。干预的平均时间为37个月,有两例显著的晚期“失败”分别发生在75个月和84个月。延伸至桥小脑角(CPA)的肿瘤生长明显快于内听道肿瘤(p = 0.0045)。未发现生长速率与年龄、性别、肿瘤位置、面神经功能及听力损失程度之间存在关联。对于一部分患者而言,保守治疗是可接受的。诊断时延伸至CPA的肿瘤生长明显快于内听道肿瘤。5年监测期内无生长并不保证肿瘤会持续呈惰性生长模式;因此必须继续监测。