Wakai Toshifumi, Shirai Yoshio, Sakata Jun, Tsuchiya Yoshiaki, Nomura Tatsuya, Hatakeyama Katsuyoshi
Division of Digestive and General Surgery, Niigata University Graduate School of Medical and Dental Sciences, Niigata, Japan.
Hepatogastroenterology. 2012 Oct;59(119):2083-8. doi: 10.5754/hge12097.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: This study aimed to evaluate whether wedge resection or S4bS5 resection was the more beneficial hepatectomy procedure for patients with locally advanced gallbladder carcinoma.
A retrospective analysis of 70 patients who underwent either wedge resection (n=58) or S4bS5 resection (n=12) for locally advanced gallbladder carcinoma without clinically evident liver metastases was conducted. Clinicopathological characteristics, histological features of hepatic invasion and surgical outcomes were analyzed.
Sixteen patients had tumors with hepatic invasion. Of the 16 patients with hepatic invasion, 6 had direct liver invasion alone and 10 had portal tract invasion featuring intrahepatic stromal invasion (n=5), intrahepatic lymphatic invasion (n=4) and intrahepatic venous invasion (n=l). The hepatectomy procedure was not significantly associated with survival after resection (p=0.518) as patients who underwent wedge resection showed an overall cumulative 3-year survival rate of 74% compared with 60% for patients who underwent S4bS5 resection. The Cox proportional hazard regression analysis revealed that pT classification (p<0.001), pM classification (p=0.001) and resection of the extrahepatic bile duct (p=0.048) were independently significant factors associated with survival after resection.
Hepatectomy procedure may not significantly affect surgical outcomes in patients with gallbladder carcinoma. Partial hepatectomy involving the gallbladder bed is critical due to possible tumor cells.
背景/目的:本研究旨在评估楔形切除术或S4bS5切除术对局部晚期胆囊癌患者而言,哪种肝切除手术更有益。
对70例因局部晚期胆囊癌接受楔形切除术(n = 58)或S4bS5切除术(n = 12)且无临床明显肝转移的患者进行回顾性分析。分析临床病理特征、肝侵犯的组织学特征和手术结果。
16例患者存在肿瘤肝侵犯。在这16例有肝侵犯的患者中,6例仅存在肝脏直接侵犯,10例存在门静脉侵犯,其特征为肝内间质侵犯(n = 5)、肝内淋巴侵犯(n = 4)和肝内静脉侵犯(n = 1)。肝切除手术与切除后的生存率无显著相关性(p = 0.518),接受楔形切除术的患者3年总累积生存率为74%,而接受S4bS5切除术的患者为60%。Cox比例风险回归分析显示,pT分期(p < 0.001)、pM分期(p = 0.001)和肝外胆管切除(p = 0.048)是与切除后生存独立相关的显著因素。
肝切除手术可能不会显著影响胆囊癌患者的手术结果。由于可能存在肿瘤细胞,涉及胆囊床的部分肝切除术至关重要。