Verplanck W S
Anal Verbal Behav. 1992;10:45-68. doi: 10.1007/BF03392874.
A series of experiments is summarized, in historical rather than logical order. The results of these experiments indicate that one type of verbal operant, the notate, a discriminated verbal response(1) by a subject to stimuli experimentally presented, occurs in at least four kinds of situations, "concept-identification," "problem-solving," "association" and "conditioning." In two of these it becomes chained with other such operants, to form the notant-a fuller verbal statement about the environment, or the monent-a self-administered instruction, that is, an S(D) for further behavior. All three classes of operant, each behaving slightly differently from one another in behavior, seem to constitute the behavioral basis of statements about "hypotheses." Unlike "mediating responses," or "processes," these verbal behaviors are not theoretically inferred, or indirectly manipulated, but rather are subject to direct experimental investigation. The relationship of their strength to the strength of the behaviors that they control is demonstrable.
一系列实验按历史而非逻辑顺序进行了总结。这些实验结果表明,一种言语操作性行为,即“标记”,是受试者对实验呈现的刺激做出的一种有区别的言语反应(1),至少出现在四种情境中:“概念识别”、“问题解决”、“联想”和“条件作用”。在其中两种情境中,它与其他此类操作性行为相连,形成“注释”——关于环境的更完整言语陈述,或“指令”——自我执行的指令,即进一步行为的S(D)。这三类操作性行为在行为上彼此略有不同,似乎构成了关于“假设”陈述的行为基础。与“中介反应”或“过程”不同,这些言语行为不是理论上推断出来的,也不是间接操纵的,而是可以直接进行实验研究的。它们的强度与它们所控制的行为强度之间的关系是可以证明的。