Department of Psychology, University College London, London, UK.
Int J Psychol. 2012;47(6):448-59. doi: 10.1080/00207594.2012.658054. Epub 2012 Apr 11.
This was a crosscultural study that focused on sex differences in self- and other-estimates of multiple intelligences (including 10 that were specified by Gardner, 1999 and three by Sternberg, 1988) as well as in an overall general intelligence estimate. It was one of a programmatic series of studies done in over 30 countries that has demonstrated the female "humility" and male "hubris" effect in self-estimated and other-estimated intelligence. Two hundred and thirty Russian university students estimated their own and their parents' overall intelligence and "multiple intelligences." Results revealed no sex difference in estimates of overall intelligence for both self and parents, but men rated themselves higher on spatial intelligence. This contradicted many previous findings in the area which have shown that men rate their own overall intelligence and mathematical intelligence significantly higher than do women. Regressions indicated that estimates of verbal, logical, and spatial intelligences were the best predictors of estimates of overall intelligence, which is a consistent finding over many studies. Regressions also showed that participants' openness to experience and self-respect were good predictors of intelligence estimates. A comparison with a British sample showed that Russians gave higher mother estimates, and were less likely to believe that IQ tests measure intelligence. Results were discussed in relation to the influence of gender role stereotypes on lay conception of intelligence across cultures.
这是一项跨文化研究,重点关注自我和他人对多种智力(包括 Gardner 1999 年指定的 10 种和 Sternberg 1988 年指定的 3 种)以及整体一般智力估计的性别差异。它是在 30 多个国家进行的一系列计划研究中的一项,这些研究表明了女性的“谦逊”和男性的“傲慢”效应,表现在自我和他人对智力的估计上。230 名俄罗斯大学生估计了自己和父母的整体智力和“多种智力”。结果显示,自我和父母对整体智力的估计没有性别差异,但男性在空间智力方面的自我评价更高。这与该领域的许多先前发现相矛盾,这些发现表明,男性对自己的整体智力和数学智力的评价明显高于女性。回归分析表明,言语、逻辑和空间智力的估计是整体智力估计的最佳预测指标,这是许多研究中的一致发现。回归分析还表明,参与者对经验的开放程度和自我尊重是智力估计的良好预测指标。与英国样本的比较表明,俄罗斯人对母亲的评价更高,并且不太相信智商测试能衡量智力。研究结果与性别角色刻板印象对跨文化智力的影响进行了讨论。