Department of Neurology and Headache Centre, University Duisburg-Essen, Hufelandstrasse 55, 45147 Essen, Germany.
Cephalalgia. 2012 May;32(7):571-7. doi: 10.1177/0333102412444012. Epub 2012 Apr 23.
Data on clinical differences between episodic (eCH) and chronic cluster headache (cCH) and accompanying migraine features are limited.
History and clinical features of 209 consecutive cluster headache patients (144 eCH, 65 cCH; male:female ratio 3.4 : 1) were obtained in a tertiary headache centre by face-to-face interviews. Relationship between occurrence of accompanying symptoms, pain intensity, comorbid migraine, and circannual and circadian rhythmicity was analysed.
99.5% of patients reported a minimum of one ipsilateral cranial autonomic symptom (CAS); 80% showed at least three CAS. A seasonal rhythmicity was observed in both eCH and cCH. A comorbid headache disorder occurred in 25%. No significant difference was detected between patients with comorbid migraine and without regarding occurrence of phonophobia, photophobia or nausea during cluster attacks. Patients with comorbid migraine reported allodynia significantly (p = 0.022) more often during cluster attacks than patients without comorbid migraine.
Occurrence of CAS and attack frequency, as well as periodic patterns of attacks, are relatively uniform in eCH and cCH. Multiple CAS are not related to pain intensity. Allodynia during cluster attacks is a frequent symptom. The unexpectedly high rate of accompanying migrainous features during cluster attacks cannot be explained by comorbid migraine.
关于发作性(eCH)和慢性丛集性头痛(cCH)之间的临床差异以及伴随偏头痛特征的数据有限。
通过面对面访谈,在一个三级头痛中心获得了 209 例连续丛集性头痛患者(144 例 eCH,65 例 cCH;男女比例为 3.4:1)的病史和临床特征。分析了伴随症状、疼痛强度、伴发偏头痛、年周期和昼夜节律之间的关系。
99.5%的患者报告至少有一次同侧颅自主神经症状(CAS);80%的患者至少有三种 CAS。eCH 和 cCH 均观察到季节性节律。25%的患者存在伴发性头痛障碍。在丛集性头痛发作期间,伴有偏头痛和不伴有偏头痛的患者之间,在畏声、畏光或恶心的发生率方面无显著差异。伴有偏头痛的患者在丛集性头痛发作期间报告的触诱发痛明显(p=0.022)更频繁。
CAS 的发生和发作频率,以及发作的周期性模式,在 eCH 和 cCH 中相对一致。多 CAS 与疼痛强度无关。在丛集性头痛发作期间出现触诱发痛是一种常见症状。在丛集性头痛发作期间出现伴随偏头痛特征的意外高发生率不能用伴发性偏头痛来解释。