Lai T-H, Fuh J-L, Wang S-J
Department of Neurology, National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2009 Oct;80(10):1116-9. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.2008.157743. Epub 2008 Oct 17.
Cranial autonomic symptoms (CAS) are distinguishing features of trigeminal autonomic cephalalgias, of which cluster headache (CH) is the most common, but they can occur in patients with migraine. For migraine with strictly unilateral headache, the presence of CAS might cause diagnostic confusion with CH. Characteristics of CAS in migraine and comparisons with those in CH have rarely been reported.
This study prospectively recruited consecutive patients with migraine and CH treated at a headache clinic. Six CAS items were surveyed, including: conjunctival injection, lacrimation, nasal congestion, rhinorrhoea, eyelid oedema and forehead/facial sweating. The CAS characteristics recorded included: laterality, intensity, time sequence and consistency with headache attacks.
A total of 786 migraine patients (625 women/161 men, mean age 40 (13) years) and 98 CH patients (11 women/87 men, mean age 36 (11) years) were recruited. The prevalence of > or =1 CAS in migraine patients was 56% and did not differ among migraine subtypes. Except for forehead/facial sweating, the features of the other CAS differed between patients with migraine and CH: CAS in migraine tended to be bilateral (OR 5.8-23.8 among different CAS), be unrestricted to the headache sides (OR 5.0-20.4), appear with mild to moderate intensity (OR 1.7-7.7) and be inconsistent with headache attacks (OR 2.8-6.7).
CAS were present in half of our migraine patients and the clinical features may help differentiate migraine from CH.
颅自主神经症状(CAS)是三叉神经自主性头痛的显著特征,其中丛集性头痛(CH)最为常见,但也可出现在偏头痛患者中。对于严格单侧头痛的偏头痛患者,CAS的存在可能导致与CH的诊断混淆。偏头痛中CAS的特征及其与CH的比较鲜有报道。
本研究前瞻性招募了在头痛门诊接受治疗的连续性偏头痛和CH患者。调查了6项CAS项目,包括:结膜充血、流泪、鼻充血、流涕、眼睑水肿和前额/面部出汗。记录的CAS特征包括:侧别、强度、时间顺序以及与头痛发作的一致性。
共招募了786例偏头痛患者(625例女性/161例男性,平均年龄40(13)岁)和98例CH患者(11例女性/87例男性,平均年龄36(11)岁)。偏头痛患者中≥1项CAS的患病率为56%,在偏头痛各亚型中无差异。除前额/面部出汗外,偏头痛和CH患者的其他CAS特征有所不同:偏头痛中的CAS倾向于双侧性(不同CAS的OR为5.8 - 23.8),不限于头痛侧(OR为5.0 - 20.4),强度为轻至中度(OR为1.7 - 7.7)且与头痛发作不一致(OR为2.8 - 6.7)。
我们的偏头痛患者中有一半存在CAS,其临床特征可能有助于偏头痛与CH的鉴别。