Spierings C, Poels P J, Sijben N, Gabreëls F J, Renier W O
Institute of Neurology, St. Radboud Hospital, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1990 Oct;32(10):865-71. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.1990.tb08098.x.
The medical histories of 84 children who had been diagnosed as having conversion disorder were reviewed in a follow-up study, and the validity of this diagnosis was examined. The female:male ratio was 2.1:1, although below the age of 10 the ratio was almost equal. The medical histories of 62 per cent of the patients showed an organic illness, and 51 per cent had various slight to moderate EEG disturbances. The validity of the diagnosis was very high: only five were found to have organic disease during the follow-up period. Children with symptoms of conversion disorder should receive appropriate medical investigations, but the authors question whether extensive investigations could not be replaced by screening tests, combined with early psychiatric intervention.
在一项随访研究中,对84名被诊断患有转换障碍的儿童的病史进行了回顾,并对该诊断的有效性进行了检查。男女比例为2.1:1,不过在10岁以下,该比例几乎相等。62%的患者病史显示有器质性疾病,51%有各种轻度至中度的脑电图紊乱。诊断的有效性非常高:在随访期间仅发现5例患有器质性疾病。有转换障碍症状的儿童应接受适当的医学检查,但作者质疑广泛的检查是否不能被筛查测试及早期精神科干预所取代。