Lawrence Rachael
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2012 Aug;76(8):1078-81. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2012.04.020. Epub 2012 May 15.
Controversy has surrounded the procedure of pediatric septoplasty since the 1950s due to concerns over an adverse effect on nasal and facial growth. However, more recent evidence has demonstrated that septoplasty can be safely performed without affecting nasal and facial development in the appropriately selected pediatric patient. The purpose of this article is to establish the impact of pediatric septoplasty on nasal and facial growth and review the clinical indications and evidence for timing of surgery according to the most recent literature.
A structured review of the PubMed, Ovid Medline and Cochrane Collaboration databases (Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Cochrane Database of Systemic Reviews) was undertaken, using the terms: pediatric, childhood, septoplasty, nasal septum, indications, nasal growth and facial growth.
Three long term follow up studies using anthropometric measurements were identified which concluded that pediatric septoplasty does not interfere with normal nasal or facial development. A further similar study concluded that external septoplasty does not affect most aspects of nasal and facial growth, but may negatively influence growth of the nasal dorsum. Furthermore, one study demonstrated that a group of children with symptomatic uncorrected deviated nasal septum had a statistically significant increased occurrence of facial and dental anomalies compared with age and sex matched controls, therefore supporting a role for septoplasty.
Evidence exists to support that pediatric septoplasty can be performed without affecting most aspects of nasal and facial growth. Furthermore, not performing or delaying septoplasty when indicated may adversely affect nasal and facial growth with compounding adverse effects in terms of deformity and asymmetry. Despite the majority advocating the timing of septal surgery to be 6 years and older, more clinical studies are required that may provide further evidence for correction of septal deviations in younger children, perhaps even at birth.
自20世纪50年代以来,由于担心小儿鼻中隔成形术会对鼻腔和面部生长产生不良影响,围绕该手术一直存在争议。然而,最近的证据表明,在适当选择的儿科患者中,鼻中隔成形术可以安全地进行,而不会影响鼻腔和面部发育。本文的目的是确定小儿鼻中隔成形术对鼻腔和面部生长的影响,并根据最新文献综述手术时机的临床指征和证据。
对PubMed、Ovid Medline和Cochrane协作数据库(Cochrane对照试验中心注册库、Cochrane系统评价数据库)进行结构化检索,检索词为:儿科、儿童期、鼻中隔成形术、鼻中隔、指征、鼻腔生长和面部生长。
确定了三项使用人体测量学进行长期随访的研究,这些研究得出结论,小儿鼻中隔成形术不会干扰正常的鼻腔或面部发育。另一项类似研究得出结论,外鼻中隔成形术不会影响鼻腔和面部生长的大多数方面,但可能对鼻背的生长产生负面影响。此外,一项研究表明,一组有症状的未经矫正的鼻中隔偏曲儿童与年龄和性别匹配的对照组相比,面部和牙齿异常的发生率在统计学上显著增加,因此支持鼻中隔成形术的作用。
有证据支持小儿鼻中隔成形术可以在不影响鼻腔和面部生长的大多数方面的情况下进行。此外,在有指征时不进行或延迟鼻中隔成形术可能会对鼻腔和面部生长产生不利影响,并在畸形和不对称方面产生复合不良影响。尽管大多数人主张鼻中隔手术的时机为6岁及以上,但仍需要更多的临床研究,可能会为更小的儿童甚至出生时矫正鼻中隔偏曲提供进一步的证据。