Bobby Zachariah, Radhika M R, Nandeesha H, Balasubramanian A, Prerna Singh, Archana Nimesh, Thippeswamy D N
Department of Biochemistry, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, Puducherry 605 006, India.
Biochem Mol Biol Educ. 2012 May-Jun;40(3):169-73. doi: 10.1002/bmb.20611.
The graduate medical students often get less opportunity for clarifying their doubts and to reinforce their concepts after lecture classes. Assessment of the effect of MCQ preparation by graduate medical students as a revision exercise on the topic "Mineral metabolism." At the end of regular teaching module on the topic "Mineral metabolism," graduate medical students were asked to prepare the stems of 15 MCQs based on the four discriminators given for each. They were told that one of the discriminators could be the answer for the MCQ and the remaining three could be the distracters. They were further guided in their task by providing few key word(s) in the stem of the expected MCQ. In the first phase of the exercise, the students attempted the MCQ preparation individually without peer consultation. In the second phase, the students participated in small group discussion to formulate the best MCQs of the group. The effects on low, medium, and high achievers were evaluated by pre and post-tests with the same set of MCQs. Both the individual endeavor in Phase 1 and small group discussion in Phase 2 for the formulation of MCQs significantly contributed to the gain from the exercise. The gains from the individual task and from small group discussion were equal among the different categories of students. Both phases of the exercise were equally beneficial for the low, medium, and high achievers. The high and medium achievers retained the gain from the exercise even after 1 week of the exercise whereas the low achievers could not retain the gain completely. Formulation of MCQs is an effective and useful unconventional revision exercise in Biochemistry for graduate medical students.
研究生医学生在讲座课程之后,往往很少有机会澄清疑问并强化概念。评估研究生医学生准备多选题作为关于“矿物质代谢”主题的复习练习的效果。在关于“矿物质代谢”主题的常规教学模块结束时,要求研究生医学生根据为每个主题给出的四个辨别因素编写15道多选题的题干。他们被告知其中一个辨别因素可能是多选题的答案,其余三个可能是干扰项。通过在预期多选题的题干中提供几个关键词,进一步指导他们完成任务。在练习的第一阶段,学生们在没有同伴协商的情况下单独尝试编写多选题。在第二阶段,学生们参加小组讨论,以制定小组中最好的多选题。通过使用同一组多选题进行前测和后测,评估对低、中、高成绩学生的影响。第一阶段的个人努力和第二阶段制定多选题的小组讨论都对练习的收获有显著贡献。不同类别学生从个人任务和小组讨论中获得的收获是相等的。练习的两个阶段对低、中、高成绩学生同样有益。高成绩和中等成绩的学生在练习后1周仍保留了练习的收获,而低成绩学生则不能完全保留收获。编写多选题是研究生医学生在生物化学中一种有效且有用的非常规复习练习。