Consultant for the World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
BMC Public Health. 2012 Jun 7;12:415. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-12-415.
In November 2009, Sierra Leone conducted a preventive yellow fever (YF) vaccination campaign targeting individuals aged nine months and older in six health districts. The campaign was integrated with a measles follow-up campaign throughout the country targeting children aged 9-59 months. For both campaigns, the operational objective was to reach 95% of the target population. During the campaign, we used clustered lot quality assurance sampling (C-LQAS) to identify areas of low coverage to recommend timely mop-up actions.
We divided the country in 20 non-overlapping lots. Twelve lots were targeted by both vaccinations, while eight only by measles. In each lot, five clusters of ten eligible individuals were selected for each vaccine. The upper threshold (UT) was set at 90% and the lower threshold (LT) at 75%. A lot was rejected for low vaccination coverage if more than 7 unvaccinated individuals (not presenting vaccination card) were found. After the campaign, we plotted the C-LQAS results against the post-campaign coverage estimations to assess if early interventions were successful enough to increase coverage in the lots that were at the level of rejection before the end of the campaign.
During the last two days of campaign, based on card-confirmed vaccination status, five lots out of 20 (25.0%) failed for having low measles vaccination coverage and three lots out of 12 (25.0%) for low YF coverage. In one district, estimated post-campaign vaccination coverage for both vaccines was still not significantly above the minimum acceptable level (LT = 75%) even after vaccination mop-up activities.
C-LQAS during the vaccination campaign was informative to identify areas requiring mop-up activities to reach the coverage target prior to leaving the region. The only district where mop-up activities seemed to be unsuccessful might have had logistical difficulties that should be further investigated and resolved.
2009 年 11 月,塞拉利昂针对六个卫生区的 9 个月及以上年龄的人群开展了预防黄热病(YF)疫苗接种运动。该运动在全国范围内与麻疹后续运动相结合,目标人群为 9-59 个月的儿童。对于这两个运动,运营目标是覆盖 95%的目标人群。在运动期间,我们使用了整群抽样质量保证(C-LQAS)来识别覆盖范围较低的地区,以推荐及时的补救行动。
我们将该国分为 20 个不重叠的地段。12 个地段同时针对两种疫苗接种,而 8 个地段仅针对麻疹。在每个地段,为每种疫苗选择了五个十个合格个体的集群。上限(UT)设定为 90%,下限(LT)设定为 75%。如果发现超过 7 名未接种疫苗的个体(未出示疫苗接种卡),则该地段因接种率低而被拒绝。运动结束后,我们将 C-LQAS 结果与运动后覆盖范围的估计值进行比较,以评估早期干预措施是否足以提高在运动结束前处于拒绝水平的地段的覆盖范围。
在运动的最后两天,根据卡片确认的接种状态,20 个地段中有 5 个(25.0%)因麻疹接种率低而失败,12 个地段中有 3 个(25.0%)因 YF 接种率低而失败。在一个地区,即使在接种补种活动之后,两种疫苗的估计运动后接种率仍未显著高于最低可接受水平(LT=75%)。
在疫苗接种运动期间,C-LQAS 是一种有用的方法,可以识别需要进行补种活动以在离开该地区之前达到覆盖目标的地区。只有一个地区的补种活动似乎不成功,可能存在后勤困难,应进一步调查和解决。