Smarick Sean D, Haskins Steve C, Boller Manuel, Fletcher Daniel J
AVETS, Monroeville, PA 15146, USA.
J Vet Emerg Crit Care (San Antonio). 2012 Jun;22 Suppl 1:S85-101. doi: 10.1111/j.1476-4431.2012.00754.x.
To systematically examine the evidence for interventions after the return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) on outcomes from veterinary cardiopulmonary resuscitation and to determine important knowledge gaps.
Standardized, systematic evaluation of the literature, categorization of relevant articles according to level of evidence and quality, and development of consensus on conclusions for application of the concepts to clinical post-cardiac arrest care.
Academia, referral practice, and general practice.
Fifteen standardized clinical questions important for post-cardiac arrest care were asked and research articles relevant to answering these questions were identified through structured, explicit literature database searches. The majority of these articles report research in species other than dogs or cats or consisted of experimental work in canine cardiac arrest models. Outcome metrics reported in these studies widely varied and ranged from quantification of mechanistic endpoints, such as elaboration of reactive oxygen species, to survival, and functional neurologic outcome.
Despite the near complete absence of clinical veterinary studies, the process allowed the formulation of statements for several postcardiac arrest treatments that were either supportive, such as mild therapeutic hypothermia or controlled reoxygenation, or neutral, such as for mannitol administration or seizure prophylaxis. Evidence grading allowed transparency in regards to the strength of these recommendations. Moreover, numerous knowledge gaps emerged that will allow generation of a road map for progress in veterinary post-cardiac arrest care.
系统审查自主循环恢复(ROSC)后干预措施对兽医心肺复苏结局影响的证据,并确定重要的知识空白。
对文献进行标准化、系统评价,根据证据水平和质量对相关文章进行分类,并就将这些概念应用于临床心脏骤停后护理的结论达成共识。
学术界、转诊机构和普通诊所。
提出了15个对心脏骤停后护理很重要的标准化临床问题,并通过结构化、明确的文献数据库检索确定了与回答这些问题相关的研究文章。这些文章大多报道了除犬或猫以外物种的研究,或由犬心脏骤停模型的实验工作组成。这些研究报告的结局指标差异很大,从对机制终点的量化,如活性氧的阐述,到存活率和功能性神经学结局。
尽管几乎完全没有临床兽医研究,但该过程仍能为几种心脏骤停后治疗制定声明,这些声明要么是支持性的,如轻度治疗性低温或控制性复氧,要么是中性的,如甘露醇给药或癫痫预防。证据分级使这些建议的力度具有透明度。此外,出现了许多知识空白,这将为兽医心脏骤停后护理的进展制定路线图。