Francisco Marroquín University, School of Medicine, Guatemala City, Guatemala.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2012 Jun 21;12:169. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-12-169.
Studies have highlighted the effects the use of the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist can have on lowering mortality and surgical complications. Implementation of the checklist is not easy and several barriers have been identified. Few studies have addressed personnel's acceptance and attitudes toward the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist. Determining personnel's acceptance might reflect their intention to use the checklist while their awareness and knowledge of the checklist might assess the effectiveness of the training process.
Through an anonymous self- responded questionnaire, general characteristics of the respondents (age, gender, profession and years spent studying or working at the hospital), knowledge of the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist (awareness of existence, knowledge of objectives, knowledge of correct use), acceptance of the checklist and its implementation (including personal belief of benefits of using the checklist), current use, teamwork and safety climate appreciation were determined.
Of the 147 surgical personnel who answered the questionnaire, 93.8% were aware of the existence of the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist and 88.8% of them reported knowing its objectives. More nurses than other personnel knew the checklist had to be used before the induction of anesthesia, skin incision, and before the patient leaves the operating room. Most personnel thought using the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist is beneficial and that its implementation was a good decision. Between 73.7% and 100% of nurses in public and private hospitals, respectively, reported the checklist had been used either always or almost always in the general elective surgeries they had participated in during the current year.
Despite high acceptance of the checklist among personnel, gaps in knowledge about when the checklist should be used still exist. This can jeopardize effective implementation and correct use of the checklist in hospitals in Guatemala City. Efforts should aim to universal awareness and complete knowledge on why and how the checklist should be used.
研究强调了使用世界卫生组织手术安全检查表可以降低死亡率和手术并发症的效果。检查表的实施并不容易,已经确定了几个障碍。很少有研究涉及人员对世界卫生组织手术安全检查表的接受程度和态度。确定人员的接受程度可能反映了他们使用检查表的意图,而他们对检查表的认识和了解可能评估培训过程的有效性。
通过匿名自我回答问卷,确定受访者的一般特征(年龄、性别、职业以及在医院学习或工作的年限)、对世界卫生组织手术安全检查表的了解(对存在的认识、对目标的认识、对正确使用的认识)、对检查表的接受程度及其实施(包括使用检查表的个人信念)、当前使用情况、团队合作和安全氛围评估。
在回答问卷的 147 名外科人员中,93.8%知道世界卫生组织手术安全检查表的存在,88.8%的人报告说知道其目标。与其他人员相比,护士更了解检查表必须在麻醉诱导、皮肤切开和患者离开手术室之前使用。大多数人员认为使用世界卫生组织手术安全检查表是有益的,实施该检查表是一个好决策。公立和私立医院的护士分别有 73.7%至 100%报告称,在他们今年参与的一般择期手术中,检查表要么总是要么几乎总是在使用。
尽管人员对检查表的接受程度很高,但在何时使用检查表方面仍存在知识差距。这可能危及危地马拉城医院检查表的有效实施和正确使用。应努力实现普遍认识和全面了解为什么以及如何使用检查表。