Naert Karen A, Trotter Martin J
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Calgary and Calgary Laboratory Services, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Am J Dermatopathol. 2013 Feb;35(1):74-7. doi: 10.1097/DAD.0b013e31825d4f73.
Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is considered a valuable ancillary tool for dermatopathology diagnosis, but few studies have measured IHC utilization by dermatopathologists or assessed its diagnostic utility. In a regionalized, community-based dermatopathology practice, we measured IHC utilization (total requests, specific antibodies requested, and final diagnosis) over a 12-month period. Next, we assessed diagnostic utility by comparing a preliminary "pre-IHC" diagnosis based on routine histochemical staining with the final diagnosis rendered after consideration of IHC results. The dermatopathology IHC utilization rate was 1.2%, averaging 3.6 stains requested per case. Melanocytic, hematolymphoid, and fibrohistiocytic lesions made up 23%, 18%, and 16%, respectively, of the total cases requiring IHC. S100 and Melan A were the most frequently requested stains, ordered on 50% and 34% of IHC cases, respectively. The utility study revealed that IHC changed the diagnosis in 11%, confirmed a diagnosis, or excluded a differential diagnosis in 77%, and was noncontributory in 4% of cases. Where IHC results prompted a change in diagnosis, 14% were a change from a benign to malignant lesion, whereas 32% changed from one malignant entity to another. IHC is most commonly used in cutaneous melanocytic and hematolymphoid lesions. In 11% of dermatopathology cases in which IHC is used, information is provided that changes the H&E diagnosis. Such changes may have significant treatment implications. IHC is noncontributory in only a small percentage of cases.
免疫组织化学(IHC)被认为是皮肤病理学诊断的一种有价值的辅助工具,但很少有研究测量皮肤病理学家对IHC的使用情况或评估其诊断效用。在一个基于社区的区域化皮肤病理学实践中,我们测量了12个月期间的IHC使用情况(总请求数、所请求的特定抗体以及最终诊断)。接下来,我们通过比较基于常规组织化学染色的初步“IHC前”诊断与考虑IHC结果后做出的最终诊断来评估诊断效用。皮肤病理学IHC使用率为1.2%,平均每个病例请求3.6次染色。黑素细胞性、血液淋巴性和纤维组织细胞性病变分别占需要IHC的总病例数的23%、18%和16%。S100和Melan A是最常被请求的染色剂,分别在50%和34%的IHC病例中被订购。效用研究表明,IHC在11%的病例中改变了诊断,在77%的病例中证实了诊断或排除了鉴别诊断,在4%的病例中无贡献。在IHC结果促使诊断改变的情况下,14%是从良性病变变为恶性病变,而32%是从一种恶性实体变为另一种恶性实体。IHC最常用于皮肤黑素细胞性和血液淋巴性病变。在使用IHC的皮肤病理学病例中,有11%提供了改变苏木精-伊红(H&E)诊断的信息。这种改变可能对治疗有重大影响。IHC仅在一小部分病例中无贡献。