Shi Peijian, Li Bai-Lian, Ge Feng
State Key Laboratory of Integrated Management of Pest Insects and Rodents, Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China.
Environ Entomol. 2012 Jun;41(3):714-22. doi: 10.1603/EN12058.
Temperature can notably affect development rate and intrinsic rate of increase of the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella L. The intrinsic rate of increase is usually regarded as a good measure of fitness in insects, and the constant temperature at which the intrinsic rate of increase reaches its maximum is defined as the "optimal" temperature for an insect species to survive. The estimates of optimal temperature for some insects and mites are ~30°C. However, the Sharpe-Schoolfield-Ikemoto model provides an estimate about the intrinsic optimum temperature at which the probability of an enzyme being in the active state is maximal. The intrinsic optimum temperature is considered to be the most suitable temperature for an insect species to survive. The estimates of intrinsic optimum temperature for some insects and mites are ~20°C. The optimal temperature and the intrinsic optimum temperature of the diamondback moth were estimated in the current study. The former estimate is 28.4 (95% CI: 26.2-28.8°C), whereas the latter estimate is 19.4°C (95% CI: 17.9-20.5°C). Considering the daily average air temperatures during the peaks of the diamondback moth in China, the intrinsic optimum temperature of 19.4°C might represent the most suitable temperature for this insect to survive. We also discussed whether it is sounded to use the intrinsic rate of increase as the fitness. Because the intrinsic rate of increase cannot reflect the density-dependence of population and the trade-off between individual body mass and population size, it is inappropriate to equate these two concepts.
温度会显著影响小菜蛾(Plutella xylostella L.)的发育速率和内禀增长率。内禀增长率通常被视为衡量昆虫适合度的一个良好指标,内禀增长率达到最大值时的恒定温度被定义为某一昆虫物种生存的“最适”温度。一些昆虫和螨类的最适温度估计约为30°C。然而,夏普 - 斯库菲尔德 - 池本模型提供了一个关于内禀最适温度的估计值,即在该温度下酶处于活性状态的概率最大。内禀最适温度被认为是某一昆虫物种生存的最合适温度。一些昆虫和螨类的内禀最适温度估计约为20°C。在本研究中对小菜蛾的最适温度和内禀最适温度进行了估计。前者的估计值为28.4(95%置信区间:26.2 - 28.8°C),而后者的估计值为19.4°C(95%置信区间:17.9 - 20.5°C)。考虑到中国小菜蛾发生高峰期的日平均气温,19.4°C的内禀最适温度可能代表了该昆虫生存的最合适温度。我们还讨论了将内禀增长率用作适合度指标是否合理。由于内禀增长率不能反映种群的密度依赖性以及个体体重与种群大小之间的权衡,将这两个概念等同起来是不合适的。