Department of Public Health Sciences, School of PublicHealth, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Heart. 2012 Jul;98(14):1072-7. doi: 10.1136/heartjnl-2012-301743.
It is vigorously debated whether pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccination (PPV) reduces risk of acute coronary syndrome (ACS) events in patients with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP).
Clinical data were prospectively collected on a population-based cohort of adults presenting with CAP in Edmonton (Alberta, Canada). Multivariable Cox models and propensity matching were used to examine the association between PPV status and ACS events within 90 days of pneumonia. Sensitivity analyses related to PPV administration (before pneumonia vs after) and duration of benefit (90 days vs 1 year) were conducted to rule out confounding.
Overall, 6171 patients were included; mean age 59 (SD 21) years, 53% male subjects, 18% had ischaemic heart disease and 2738 (44%) were hospitalised. Within 90 days of pneumonia, ACS events occurred in 175 (3%) patients and most were non-fatal (162 (93%)). In multivariable analyses, PPV exposure was associated with a 58% reduction in ACS events (12 vs 16 events per 100 patient-years, adjusted HR (aHR) 0.42 (0.27 to 0.66)) and results were nearly identical with propensity matching (aHR 0.46 (0.28 to 0.73)). However, indepth sensitivity analyses, with some with large assumptions, could not refute the existence of a small protective benefit of PPV.
Even after extensive adjustment using clinical data, the authors observed that PPV exposure was associated with a 60% reduction in ACS events among patients with pneumonia. Sensitivity analyses demonstrated that these findings, at least in part, were probably a result of confounding, most likely the 'healthy-vaccinee' effect. Previous observational studies using administrative data suggesting a very large protective benefit of PPV on ACS events may have been heavily confounded.
肺炎球菌多糖疫苗(PPV)接种是否降低社区获得性肺炎(CAP)患者发生急性冠状动脉综合征(ACS)事件的风险存在激烈争论。
在加拿大阿尔伯塔省埃德蒙顿进行的一项基于人群的 CAP 成年患者队列的前瞻性临床数据收集。多变量 Cox 模型和倾向匹配用于研究肺炎后 90 天内 PPV 状况与 ACS 事件之间的关联。进行了与 PPV 管理(肺炎前与肺炎后)和获益持续时间(90 天与 1 年)相关的敏感性分析,以排除混杂因素。
共纳入 6171 例患者;平均年龄 59(21)岁,53%为男性,18%患有缺血性心脏病,2738 例(44%)住院。肺炎后 90 天内,ACS 事件发生在 175 例(3%)患者中,大多数是非致命的(162 例(93%))。多变量分析显示,PPV 暴露与 ACS 事件减少 58%相关(每 100 例患者年发生 12 例与 16 例事件,调整后的 HR(aHR)0.42(0.27 至 0.66)),并且倾向匹配的结果几乎相同(aHR 0.46(0.28 至 0.73))。然而,深入的敏感性分析(其中一些有较大的假设)无法反驳 PPV 存在较小的保护作用。
即使使用临床数据进行了广泛的调整,作者观察到肺炎患者中 PPV 暴露与 ACS 事件减少 60%相关。敏感性分析表明,这些发现至少部分可能是混杂的结果,最可能是“健康接种者”效应。以前使用行政数据的观察性研究表明,PPV 对 ACS 事件有很大的保护作用,可能受到严重混杂。