Bispebjerg Hospital and Centre for Healthy Ageing, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Institute of Sports Medicine-Copenhagen, Denmark.
Ultraschall Med. 2012 Oct;33(5):441-6. doi: 10.1055/s-0032-1312923. Epub 2012 Jun 28.
Elasticity imaging is a relatively new ultrasound-based technique for investigating musculoskeletal injury. Sonoelastography (SEL), the most commonly used technique, allows determination of the elastic properties of tissue by applying pressure.
To critically evaluate the literature regarding the use of SEL in the diagnosis of tendon and muscle alterations.
This review includes a systematic literature search performed on major electronic databases. Eight articles were included. The GRADE approach was used to evaluate the quality of evidence presented in the included articles and the strength of their recommendations.
The results on human tendon disorders showed that the SEL findings correlated extremely well with conventional ultrasound (US) findings as well as with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and clinical examination. In some articles SEL was found to be even more sensitive than conventional ultrasound and in addition capable of identifying subclinical alterations that conventional ultrasound could not. For skeletal muscle, a close correlation between SEL and US and MRI was found, although there is only one article on the topic. SEL was found to be able to distinguish between healthy and diseased muscles and was potentially more sensitive in identifying early dystrophic changes than US or MRI.
Based on this critical evaluation of the literature, SEL seems to be at least as feasible as US and MRI for assessing tendon alterations and able to identify subclinical tendon alterations not visible with conventional US. The findings in the reviewed articles suggest that SEL could become a supplementary imaging technique in the assessment of musculoskeletal alterations, potentially superior to US and MRI. Until more studies are available, SEL has to be viewed as an experimental examination without sufficient supporting evidence to be used as a routine examination equivalent to US and MRI.
弹性成像是一种相对较新的基于超声的技术,用于研究肌肉骨骼损伤。声弹性成像(SEL)是最常用的技术,通过施加压力来确定组织的弹性特性。
批判性评估关于 SEL 在诊断肌腱和肌肉改变中的应用的文献。
本综述包括对主要电子数据库进行的系统文献检索。共纳入 8 篇文章。使用 GRADE 方法评估纳入文章中证据的质量及其推荐的强度。
关于人类肌腱疾病的结果表明,SEL 发现与常规超声(US)发现以及磁共振成像(MRI)和临床检查非常吻合。在一些文章中,SEL 被发现比常规超声更敏感,并且能够识别常规超声无法识别的亚临床改变。对于骨骼肌,SEL 与 US 和 MRI 之间存在密切相关性,尽管关于该主题只有一篇文章。SEL 能够区分健康和患病的肌肉,并且在识别早期的营养不良变化方面比 US 或 MRI 更敏感。
基于对文献的批判性评估,SEL 似乎至少与 US 和 MRI 一样可行,可用于评估肌腱改变,并能够识别常规 US 无法看到的亚临床肌腱改变。综述文章中的发现表明,SEL 可能成为评估肌肉骨骼改变的辅助成像技术,潜在优于 US 和 MRI。在更多研究可用之前,SEL 必须被视为一种实验性检查,没有足够的支持证据可作为与 US 和 MRI 等效的常规检查。