Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
Curr Opin Pulm Med. 2012 Sep;18(5):506-16. doi: 10.1097/MCP.0b013e3283560809.
Ever since sarcoidosis was first described, its relationship with tuberculosis has been debated. Whereas some consider sarcoidosis and tuberculosis as two extremes of the same disease process, other researchers have negated the role of mycobacteria in causation of sarcoidosis. Whether or not linked causally, there are obvious clinical similarities that make differential diagnosis of the two conditions very challenging, particularly in countries with high burden of tuberculosis. Herein we analyze the relationship between sarcoidosis and tuberculosis and its implications in clinical practice.
Initial studies had focused on finding an epidemiological link between the two conditions or demonstration of mycobacteria in sarcoid lesions on histology. Results from these studies were at best suggestive. Recent molecular and immunological studies suggest mycobacterial antigens are the inciting agents in a proportion of sarcoidosis patients. Evidence is stronger from countries with high burden of tuberculosis. Tuberculosis can manifest as a complication of treatment in sarcoidosis and the two conditions can rarely co-exist.
The balance of evidence favors mycobacteria or their products as a trigger for inciting immune responses leading to sarcoidosis in a proportion of patients, which is likely to be higher in countries with high tuberculosis burden. This evidence also highlights the limitations of molecular or serological studies to discriminate between the two conditions.
自从结节病首次被描述以来,其与结核病的关系一直存在争议。一些人认为结节病和结核病是同一疾病过程的两个极端,而其他研究人员则否定了分枝杆菌在结节病发病机制中的作用。无论是否存在因果关系,这两种疾病在临床上有明显的相似之处,使得鉴别诊断非常具有挑战性,尤其是在结核病负担较高的国家。在此,我们分析了结节病和结核病之间的关系及其在临床实践中的意义。
最初的研究集中在寻找这两种疾病之间的流行病学联系,或在组织学上显示结节病病变中的分枝杆菌。这些研究的结果充其量只是提示性的。最近的分子和免疫学研究表明,分枝杆菌抗原是一部分结节病患者发病的始动因素。在结核病负担较高的国家,证据更强。结核病可作为结节病治疗的并发症出现,这两种疾病很少同时存在。
综上所述,证据倾向于认为分枝杆菌或其产物作为触发因素,引起一部分患者的免疫反应,导致结节病,而在结核病负担较高的国家,这种情况可能更为常见。这一证据也突出了分子或血清学研究在鉴别这两种疾病方面的局限性。