Department of Neurosurgery, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32610, USA.
J Neurointerv Surg. 2013 Sep 1;5(5):497-500. doi: 10.1136/neurintsurg-2012-010430. Epub 2012 Jul 6.
Over the past several decades, checklists have emerged in a variety of different patient care settings to help reduce medical errors and ensure patient safety. To date, there have been no published accounts demonstrating the effectiveness of checklists designed specifically for the unique demands of neurointerventional procedures.
A three-part, 20-item checklist was developed specific to neurointerventional procedures using the WHO surgical checklist as a template. Staff members (nurses, radiation technologists and physicians) were surveyed regarding near-miss adverse events and the quality of communication immediately following each neurointerventional procedure for 4 weeks prior to implementation of the checklist and again for 4 weeks after using the checklist. Staff members were asked to complete final surveys at the end of the study period.
71 procedures were performed during the 4 weeks prior to checklist implementation and 60 procedures were performed during the 4 weeks after institution of the checklist. Post-checklist surveys indicated significantly improved communication compared with pre-checklist surveys (χ(2) 29.4, p<0.001). The number of adverse events was lower after checklist implementation for eight of the nine adverse event types (not individually significant), but the total number of adverse events was significantly lower after checklist implementation (χ(2) 11.4, p=0.001). Final staff surveys were uniformly positive with 95% of individuals indicating that the checklist should be continued in the department.
Use of a neurointerventional procedural checklist resulted in statistically significant improvements in team communication and a significant reduction in total adverse events, with uniformly positive staff feedback.
在过去的几十年中,各种不同的患者护理环境中都出现了检查表,以帮助减少医疗错误并确保患者安全。迄今为止,尚无文献报道专门针对神经介入手术独特需求而设计的检查表的有效性。
使用世界卫生组织手术检查表作为模板,为神经介入手术专门开发了三部分,共 20 项检查表。在实施检查表之前的四周和之后的四周内,调查员就神经介入手术中发生的接近不良事件和沟通质量对医护人员(护士、放射技术人员和医生)进行了调查。在研究结束时,工作人员被要求完成最终调查。
在实施检查表之前的四周内进行了 71 例手术,在实施检查表之后的四周内进行了 60 例手术。与检查表实施前的调查相比,检查表实施后的沟通明显改善(χ²29.4,p<0.001)。在实施检查表后,有九种不良事件类型中的八种的不良事件数量有所下降(但无统计学意义),但总的不良事件数量明显减少(χ²11.4,p=0.001)。最终的工作人员调查结果均为正面,95%的人表示该检查表应在该部门继续使用。
使用神经介入手术检查表可显著改善团队沟通,并显著减少总不良事件,同时得到工作人员的一致好评。